Why does God choose to "no longer have compassion" in Zechariah 11:6? Verse Under Consideration “For I will no longer have compassion on the inhabitants of the land,” declares the LORD. “But behold, I will hand every man over to his neighbor and his king. They will devastate the land, and I will not deliver it from their hands.” (Zechariah 11:6) Immediate Literary Context Zechariah 11 forms the first part of the prophet’s second oracle (chapters 11–14). Verses 4–17 are an enacted parable: Zechariah plays the role of a shepherd who first cares for the flock, then breaks two staffs—“Favor” (ḥēn, v. 10) and “Union” (ḥōḇəlîm, v. 14)—symbolizing the withdrawal of God’s covenant blessings and national cohesion. The “flock doomed to slaughter” (v. 4) is Judah/Israel. Verse 6 announces the turning‐point: God’s protection is suspended; judgment falls. Historical Setting Zechariah ministered c. 520–518 BC, shortly after the first return from Babylon (Ezra 1–6). A rebuilt temple was underway, but widespread spiritual apathy, corrupt leadership (cf. Malachi 1:6–8), and social injustice (Zechariah 7:9–12) persisted. The vision reaches beyond Zechariah’s day to Messiah’s first advent and the destruction of Jerusalem in AD 70, as signaled by the thirty pieces of silver (v. 12; fulfilled in Matthew 26:14–15; 27:3–10). The Meaning of “No Longer Have Compassion” 1. Hebrew racham denotes covenantal pity rooted in faithful love (e.g., Deuteronomy 13:17; Hosea 1:6). 2. To “no longer have compassion” is therefore a judicial declaration that the covenantal safety net is removed. The people have forfeited protective mercy by persistent disobedience and rejection of God’s appointed shepherd. Biblical Reasons for the Withdrawal • Persistent Rebellion: Zechariah’s audience had again hardened their hearts (7:11–12). God’s long‐suffering (Nehemiah 9:30–31) reaches a limit when it would endorse sin (Isaiah 1:15). • Social Injustice: Leaders “buy and sell” the flock (11:5), echoing covenant curses for oppression (Deuteronomy 28:29–34). • Rejection of Messiah: The shepherd’s wages of thirty silver coins—price of a slave (Exodus 21:32)—foreshadow Israel’s contempt for Jesus, the Good Shepherd (John 10:11). Once Messiah is rejected, the staff “Favor” is broken; compassion is paused. • Covenant Sanctions: Deuteronomy 28:49–68 predicts foreign invasion, siege, and exile if Israel spurns the LORD. Zechariah 11:6 is the prophetic activation of those sanctions. “Handed Over to His Neighbor and His King” First, civil strife—“his neighbor”—erupts (Josephus, War 2.17.9 speaks of brutal factionalism in AD 66–70). Second, an external sovereign—“his king”—subjugates them. Historically this culminated in Rome’s Titus razing Jerusalem in AD 70; prophetically it foreshadows future tribulation (cf. Luke 19:41–44). Does Compassion Cease Forever? No. Zechariah’s very next oracle (12:10) promises, “They will look on Me, the One they have pierced,” and mourn in repentance; chapter 14 depicts final deliverance. Hosea 1:6–7 shows the same pattern: “I will no longer have compassion… yet I will deliver them by the LORD their God.” Divine compassion pauses for discipline, not annihilation (Hebrews 12:6). Theological Synthesis God’s attributes never conflict. Holiness demands justice; love extends mercy. When mercy is spurned, justice prevails until repentance occurs. Zechariah 11:6 dramatizes Romans 11:22—“Consider therefore the kindness and severity of God.” Practical and Evangelistic Implications 1. Sin invites severe but purposeful discipline; delay not your repentance. 2. Rejection of the Shepherd leaves one at the mercy of “worthless shepherds” (11:17)—whether political, ideological, or spiritual. 3. God’s temporary withdrawal underscores the urgency of embracing the resurrected Christ, who alone restores “Favor” and “Union” (Acts 3:19–21). Summary God “no longer has compassion” in Zechariah 11:6 because His covenant people, after exhaustive patience, reject His rule, oppress one another, and spurn the coming Messiah. In righteous response, He removes His protective mercy, allowing internal anarchy and foreign domination, yet always with the redemptive aim of ultimate restoration for those who repent and look to the pierced Shepherd. |
    |