Why does Jeremiah 4:10 suggest God deceived the people? Immediate Literary Context Verses 1–9 plead for Judah’s repentance; verse 10 is Jeremiah’s sudden lament as Babylon’s invasion looms (vv. 11-18). God has repeatedly warned (3:6-11; 4:5-8). The “peace” slogan came from court prophets (6:14; 8:11), not from the LORD’s mouth (23:16-17). Historical Setting After Josiah’s death (609 BC) Judah slid back into idolatry. Jehoiakim’s regime hired prophets who guaranteed political safety if proper rituals honored Yahweh alongside the gods of the nations (cf. 2 Kings 23:34-37; Jeremiah 26; Lachish Ostraca #3: lines 17-20 mention “weakening of hands,” a phrase identical to Jeremiah 38:4, showing real-time fear of Babylon). Jeremiah’s Prophetic Lament Technique Jeremiah often voices either the people’s complaint (12:1; 15:18) or his own anguish (20:7 “you enticed [nashaʾ] me”). These are honest human outcries recorded without divine endorsement of every word; Scripture is infallible in what it affirms, not in every emotion it reports (Job 38-42 illustrates the same pattern). Conditional Nature of Peace Promises Jeremiah 3:12-15; 4:1-2 offer peace if Judah repents. The nation ignored the conditions, yet clung to the outcome—“peace.” When conditions are rejected, the promise is void; the resulting disaster is therefore self-inflicted, not divine trickery. Role of False Prophets and Judicial Hardening Jeremiah 14:13-16; 23:21-22 name Hananiah-type prophets who fabricate “shalom.” God allows their message as judgment on a willfully deaf nation—similar to 1 Kings 22:19-23 where a lying spirit convinces Ahab’s prophets, and 2 Thessalonians 2:10-12 where God sends “a powerful delusion” to those who refuse truth. Divine “permission” is expressed in Hebrew as direct agency; the Bible’s Semitic idiom often attributes to God what He merely permits through secondary causes. Divine Truthfulness Affirmed Numbers 23:19; Titus 1:2: God “cannot lie.” The entire biblical canon maintains this (Psalm 119:160; John 17:17). When Scripture records someone accusing God of deception, the charge is answered by the narrative itself. Jeremiah 5:1-13 and 7:1-8 immediately rebut the idea that God ever promised unconditional peace. Theological Synthesis 1. God offered genuine peace conditioned on repentance. 2. Judah preferred false prophets promising peace without repentance. 3. God sovereignly allowed those prophets to flourish as judgment. 4. Jeremiah’s lament reflects human confusion, not divine deceit. 5. Throughout, God remained consistent with His nature and His word. Practical Application Rejecting God’s conditions while claiming His promises still leads to ruin. True shalom comes only through covenant faithfulness—in the new covenant ratified by Christ’s resurrection (Jeremiah 31:31-34; Romans 5:1). |
    |