Why does Pharaoh ask for forgiveness in Exodus 10:17 despite repeatedly hardening his heart? Canonical Text “Pharaoh quickly summoned Moses and Aaron and said, ‘I have sinned against the LORD your God and against you. Now please forgive my sin once more and plead with the LORD your God to remove this death from me.’ ” (Exodus 10:16-17) Historical-Cultural Setting Egyptian rulers were considered divine intermediaries; their public concessions were rare and usually political. Asking foreign shepherds (Genesis 46:34) for intercession humiliated Pharaoh before his court. In the Egyptian “Book of the Dead,” chapter 125, a deceased soul confesses sins before 42 gods; yet no provision exists for personal, relational forgiveness. Pharaoh’s words therefore signal crisis desperation rather than covenantal repentance. The Biblical Motif of the Hardened Heart • Pharaoh “hardened his heart” (Exodus 8:15, 32; 9:34), yet “the LORD hardened Pharaoh’s heart” (Exodus 9:12; 10:20). Hebrew employs three verbs: – qāshah, “to make stubborn” – ḥāzaq, “to strengthen” – kābēd, “to make heavy,” the antonym of the Egyptian ideal “light heart” weighed against Ma’at’s feather. The narrative alternates between self-hardening and divine hardening, displaying a judicial process: Pharaoh’s freely chosen obstinacy is confirmed and intensified by God for a larger redemptive purpose (Romans 9:17-18). Sovereignty and Responsibility Exodus affirms both: 1. Human agency—Pharaoh repeatedly rejects earlier, softer warnings (Exodus 7–8). 2. Divine prerogative—God resolves to “multiply My signs” (Exodus 7:3) so “that you may know that I am the LORD” (Exodus 10:2). The pattern parallels later prophetic judgments: when sinners persist, God “gives them over” (Psalm 81:12; Romans 1:24-28). Pharaoh’s Request: Fear-Driven Remorse Pharaoh’s plea surfaces after the locusts threatened total agricultural collapse (Exodus 10:15). Egyptian inscriptions (e.g., Karnak reliefs of Seti I) record locust plagues as omens of divine anger. Pharaoh seeks relief from “this death” (collective famine). His language—“forgive my sin only this time”—betrays transactional, self-preserving motivation. Biblical repentance (šûb) requires turning to God in allegiance; Pharaoh merely seeks plague removal, then reverts (10:20). Crisis Promises in the Exodus Cycle Plague 2: “Entreat the LORD” (Exodus 8:8) → relief → hardening. Plague 4: “Pray for me” (8:28) → relief → hardening. Plague 7: “I have sinned” (9:27) → relief → hardening. Plague 8: identical pattern. The repetition underlines how external pressures can produce verbal concessions without inner change (cf. Hebrews 3:13). Polemic against Egyptian Deities The eighth plague judged Seth and Nepri, guardians of grain. When Pharaoh begs Moses, he tacitly admits Yahweh’s superiority over Egypt’s gods (Exodus 12:12). The contest culminates in Passover, prefiguring Christ, “our Passover lamb” (1 Corinthians 5:7). Archaeological Corroboration • Ipuwer Papyrus 2:10–6:1 laments, “The river is blood… grain is perished,” echoing plague imagery. • The Merneptah Stele (c. 1207 BC) confirms an Israelite presence in Canaan soon after a plausible exodus window. • Brooklyn Papyrus 35.1446 lists Semitic slaves in Egypt (18th dynasty), matching Exodus 1:11. These data refute the claim that Exodus is myth; they locate a Semitic population subject to labor and sudden departure. Typological and Theological Implications Pharaoh’s counterfeit repentance foreshadows pseudo-faith exposed by trials (Matthew 13:20-21). Conversely, genuine confession mirrors Nineveh’s king (Jonah 3:6-10). The Exodus narrative anticipates the New Covenant: God liberates, hard hearts resist, yet divine glory triumphs through judgment and salvation accomplished in the resurrection of Christ (Luke 9:31; Romans 9:23). Pastoral Application 1. Regret is not repentance. Seek heart transformation through the risen Christ (Acts 3:19). 2. Repeated sin dulls moral perception; today, “do not harden your hearts” (Hebrews 3:15). 3. God’s patience invites surrender; eventual judgment is certain (2 Peter 3:9-10). Summary Pharaoh asks for forgiveness because his circumstances become intolerable, not because he embraces Yahweh. Scripture portrays a man whose self-chosen obstinacy is judicially ratified by God, yet who momentarily utters pleas when judgment intensifies. The episode underscores divine sovereignty, human responsibility, and the necessity of authentic repentance—a lesson validated by history, archaeology, manuscript reliability, and ultimately the saving power revealed in the resurrected Christ. |
    |