Why does Hebrews 2:8 say "nothing is left outside his control" when evil still exists? Canonical Text and Immediate Context Hebrews 2:8 : “and put everything under his feet.” In putting everything under him, God left nothing that is not subject to him. Yet at present we do not see everything subject to him.” Verses 5-9 form a unit that interprets Psalm 8:4-6 and applies it to Jesus. Old Testament Background: Psalm 8 and “Under His Feet” Psalm 8:6 declares of humanity, “You made him ruler of the works of Your hands; You have placed everything under his feet.” The writer of Hebrews sees Psalm 8’s ideal human fulfilled in Christ, the “last Adam” (1 Corinthians 15:45). The Hebrew term tachath raglav (“under his feet”) and the Septuagint hupotaxai (“to subject”) denote total, judicial authority (cf. Joshua 10:24 for the ancient Near-Eastern foot-on-neck imagery of conquest). Thus “nothing left outside his control” is not hyperbole but covenantal language signaling comprehensive dominion granted by Yahweh. Exegetical Flow in Hebrews 2:5-9 1. v. 5: The “world to come” is in view, not merely the present age. 2. v. 6-7: Citation of Psalm 8 to recall humankind’s intended rule. 3. v. 8a: God objectively placed all things under the Son. 4. v. 8b: “Yet at present we do not see…” acknowledges experiential tension. 5. v. 9: We do “see Jesus,” crowned through suffering, guaranteeing fulfillment. The author therefore speaks of two spheres: the heavenly verdict already pronounced and the earthly experience still awaiting consummation. The “Already / Not Yet” Structure of Christ’s Kingship • Already: At the resurrection and ascension, the Father “seated Him at His right hand… far above every ruler” (Ephesians 1:20-22). The empty tomb—attested by the early creed in 1 Corinthians 15:3-7, recorded within a decade of Easter and corroborated by multiple independent sources—demonstrates that Christ broke the ultimate power of evil: death (Acts 2:24). • Not Yet: 1 Corinthians 15:25-28 teaches He “must reign until He has put all His enemies under His feet,” with death destroyed last. Thus evil’s final eviction awaits the parousia (Revelation 20:10-14). Divine Sovereignty and the Ongoing Reality of Evil Scripture presents three complementary truths: 1. God is absolutely sovereign (Isaiah 46:10; Daniel 4:35). 2. Evil presently operates under limited allowance (Job 1-2; Luke 22:31). 3. God employs evil’s mischief for greater good and His glory (Genesis 50:20; Romans 8:28). Hebrews 2 frames this paradox around Christ’s solidarity with humanity: He tasted death “for everyone” (v. 9) to disarm the devil (2:14). Evil’s current existence is a temporary condition that magnifies the Savior’s redemptive work and displays God’s longsuffering patience (2 Peter 3:9). Purpose of the Delay in Total Subjection 1. Salvation’s Extension: The gospel must reach all nations (Matthew 24:14). Modern missiology records unprecedented growth in regions once closed; e.g., the rapid expansion of house churches in Iran despite persecution. 2. Sanctification of the Church: Trials refine believers (James 1:2-4). 3. Public Vindication: Final judgment will reveal God’s justice universally (Revelation 15:3-4). Analogies from Creation and Design Scientific observation of finely tuned constants (e.g., the cosmological constant balanced to 1 part in 10⁵³) demonstrates purposeful calibration, consistent with Colossians 1:17: “in Him all things hold together.” The existence of entropy-driven decay within that design parallels moral evil’s present but bounded operation; the same Second Law that allows biological aging also enables essential energy transfer for life. Design thus includes temporary disorder for a greater equilibrium, mirroring redemptive history. Historical and Archaeological Corroboration of Hebrews’ Claim • Manuscripts: P46 (c. AD 175-225) contains Hebrews 2, with wording identical to modern critical texts—showing no doctrinal evolution. • Early Citation: Clement of Rome (c. AD 95) alludes to Hebrews 2:9, proving first-century acceptance. • Qumran Echoes: 4QPsalm 8 fragments retain the dominion motif, underscoring the continuity of the Psalm 8 expectation. Philosophical Considerations: Freedom, Love, and Moral Development True love and moral responsibility presuppose the capacity to choose evil. The allowance of evil, then, is not a defect in sovereignty but a requisite for creatures to genuinely love God (Deuteronomy 30:19). Christ, the second Adam, exhibits perfect obedient choice, providing both substitutionary atonement and moral exemplar. Eschatological Assurance Revelation 11:15 : “The kingdom of the world has become the kingdom of our Lord and of His Christ, and He will reign forever and ever.” The prophetic perfect tense assures completion. Geological snapshots—such as the rapid burial fossil record of the Green River Formation, matching catastrophic conditions of the Flood (Genesis 7)—demonstrate that God has intervened decisively in history before; He will do so again. Practical Ramifications for Believers • Confidence in prayer: even unmitigated evil is within Christ’s overruling scope (Romans 8:38-39). • Evangelistic urgency: the period of partial non-subjection is the season of mercy (2 Corinthians 6:2). • Hope amid suffering: present afflictions are “not worth comparing” to the coming glory (Romans 8:18). Summary Hebrews 2:8 proclaims a legal, cosmic reality grounded in the completed work of Christ: all things are already subjected under His authority. The verse simultaneously recognizes that this dominion is not yet fully manifest to human sight. Evil’s transient presence serves salvific, sanctifying, and revelatory purposes under God’s unrivaled sovereignty. The resurrection, manuscript fidelity, archaeological record, and observable design in creation converge to attest that the day is certain when “nothing left outside His control” will be universally evident, and “He will wipe away every tear” (Revelation 21:4). |
    |