Why does God allow folly to be set in high places, as stated in Ecclesiastes 10:5? Ecclesiastes 10:5—Text and Translation “There is an evil I have seen under the sun, an error that proceeds from the ruler: folly is set in many high places, while the rich sit in lowly positions.” Literary and Historical Context Ecclesiastes, written by Solomon “king over Israel in Jerusalem” (Ecclesiastes 1:12), surveys life “under the sun”—human existence in a fallen world. Chapter 10 assembles proverbs about wisdom in civic life. Verse 5 observes a recurring political inversion: unqualified or morally foolish people occupy positions of power, while those of integrity are marginalized. The rest of Scripture confirms this pattern (Psalm 12:8; Proverbs 29:2). Theological Theme: God’s Sovereignty and Human Responsibility Scripture simultaneously affirms (1) the absolute sovereignty of God over rulers (Daniel 4:17; Romans 13:1) and (2) genuine human freedom and accountability (Deuteronomy 30:19). God “removes kings and establishes them” (Daniel 2:21), yet holds each ruler responsible for justice (Jeremiah 22:3–5). Allowing folly in high places is never a lapse in divine control; it belongs to His permissive will, woven into His redemptive plan. Purposes for Allowing Folly in High Places 1. Testing and Refining the Faithful Trials expose and strengthen faith (1 Peter 1:6–7). When leaders are foolish, believers must lean on divine wisdom rather than human institutions (Psalm 118:8–9). This cultivates discernment (Hebrews 5:14) and purifies devotion (James 1:2–4). 2. Judicial Consequence for Collective Sin God sometimes gives societies over to the leaders they desire as a form of judgment (Hosea 13:11; Romans 1:24). When Israel demanded a king “like all the nations” (1 Samuel 8:5–22), the LORD granted Saul, whose folly chastened the nation and prepared the way for David. 3. Demonstration of the Superiority of Divine Wisdom The contrast between foolish rulers and God’s perfect rulership magnifies His glory (Isaiah 40:23). Human failures highlight the need for the righteous Messiah, “King of kings” (Revelation 19:16). History’s catalog of inept regimes underscores the incomparable reign of Christ. 4. Protection of Creaturely Freedom and Moral Growth Love requires freedom (Joshua 24:15). Were God to override every foolish choice, genuine virtue, civic responsibility, and moral learning would be impossible. Allowing folly in power lets humanity experience the consequences of sin, driving people to repentance (2 Chronicles 7:14). 5. Preparation for Final Judgment Present injustices set the stage for future rectification when Christ “will judge the living and the dead” (2 Timothy 4:1). Earthly inequities awaken longings for His kingdom, where folly has no place (Revelation 21:27). Scriptural Case Studies • Pharaoh (Exodus 5–14) – God “raised [him] up” to display His power (Exodus 9:16). • Nebuchadnezzar (Daniel 4) – Prideful king humbled so “all the peoples” might know heaven rules. • Rehoboam (1 Kings 12) – His recklessness split Israel, fulfilling divine prophecy (1 Kings 11:31). • Pilate & Herod (Acts 4:27–28) – Their collusion in crucifying Christ fulfilled God’s redemptive plan. Historical and Contemporary Illustrations Church historians note that persecution under Nero, Diocletian, and Communist regimes often propelled gospel expansion. Modern sociological data show underground churches multiplying where governments oppose biblical truth, confirming Genesis 50:20: “You intended evil…God intended it for good.” Behavioral studies on resilience corroborate that adversity forges communal solidarity and moral clarity. Practical Exhortations for Believers 1. Seek wisdom and excellence even when undervalued (Ecclesiastes 10:10). 2. Pray for those in authority (1 Timothy 2:1–2), including foolish leaders. 3. Engage cultural institutions with integrity (Matthew 5:13–16). 4. Anchor hope in Christ’s kingdom, not human politics (Hebrews 13:14). Conclusion God permits folly in high places to expose the bankruptcy of self-reliance, steer hearts toward His wisdom, administer justice, and prepare humanity for the reign of the resurrected Christ. Ecclesiastes 10:5 thus becomes both a realistic diagnosis of fallen societies and an invitation to trust the sovereign, redeeming purposes of Yahweh. |
    |