Psalm 35:13–14 – How can David both mourn for his foes and call down curses on them without contradiction? “But as for me, when they were sick, I wore sackcloth; I afflicted myself with fasting, but my prayers returned unanswered. I paced about as for my friend or brother; I was bowed down with grief, like one mourning for his mother.” David’s depiction of mourning on behalf of his enemies in these verses appears at first to contradict the imprecatory sections of Psalm 35 where he calls down God’s judgment upon them (e.g., Psalm 35:1–8). Below is a comprehensive look at how these two attitudes—sorrowful compassion and passionate imprecation—coexist without contradiction. 1. Historical and Literary Background The book of Psalms is a collection of worship songs, prayers, and poems that often mix personal experiences with national concerns. In Psalm 35, traditionally ascribed to David, the author pleas for deliverance from false accusers and violent adversaries. Although David’s lament and pleas for vindication might sound contradictory, they reflect the genuine tension in the heart of someone who sincerely loves righteousness yet also zealously upholds divine justice. Psalm 35 is part of what are sometimes called “imprecatory psalms” (e.g., Psalms 69, 109), wherein the psalmist seeks God’s judgment on evildoers. These psalms have long been present in the Hebrew tradition, as confirmed by multiple ancient textual witnesses, including portions of the Dead Sea Scrolls (ca. 2nd century BC to 1st century AD). The textual consistency of the Psalms in these manuscripts upholds that what we read today corresponds with remarkable fidelity to what was penned in David’s time. 2. David’s Mourning for His Foes David expresses profound empathy, describing how he identifies with his enemies’ sufferings. In Psalm 35:13–14, he says he afflicted himself with fasting when they were sick and grieved for them like someone would for “a friend or brother” or even a mother. This evokes several key points: • Genuine Compassion: David is no stranger to compassion: his grief is genuine because he recognizes that every human life holds worth before the Creator. • Personal Relationship Factor: Some of David’s “foes” were once allies or close acquaintances, making the sense of betrayal sharper and sorrow for their downfall more intense (cf. Psalm 41:9). • Godly Virtue of Mercy: Scripturally, expressions of mercy are commended. Proverbs 25:21 says, “If your enemy is hungry, give him food to eat”. David’s mourning displays that merciful attitude. This caring side to David was not unique to Psalm 35. Historical narratives (1 Samuel 24:4–7; 1 Samuel 26:8–11) show he spared King Saul’s life multiple times, even though Saul pursued David to kill him. These episodes confirm that David’s heart was capable of both defending righteousness and showing compassion to adversaries. 3. Understanding Imprecatory Prayers Imprecations are pleas for divine justice—requests that God would judge wickedness rather than the psalmist, or Israel, taking revenge by their own hand. This principle is later echoed in the New Testament, where believers are commanded: “Do not avenge yourselves, beloved, but leave room for God’s wrath” (Romans 12:19). In Psalm 35, David’s imprecatory petitions likely arise from the following motivations: • God’s Honor: David’s primary concern is that injustice and mistreatment of the righteous undermine God’s honor. He calls upon the Lord to display His just rule. • Desire for Vindication: David has been wronged and falsely accused. His appeals for God’s judgment are a cry for justice, not personal vengeance. • Covenantal Framework: Under the covenant with Israel, those who uphold righteousness enjoy God’s favor, while unrepentant sin invites judgment (Deuteronomy 11:26–28). Imprecatory prayers align with this covenantal understanding of blessing and curse. Thus, calling for God’s righteous vengeance is not necessarily a sign of hatred. Rather, it shows confidence that God, the ultimate Judge, will enact justice according to His own righteous standard. 4. Harmonizing Mourning and Judgment To modern readers, it may seem contradictory to both weep for enemies and seek God’s judgment upon them. However, key theological and emotional dimensions clarify how these two can coexist: A. Separation of Personal Desire and Divine Justice David can mourn out of personal compassion while also acknowledging that persistent evildoers, especially those who remain unrepentant, are subject to God’s righteous judgment. His fasting and prayer represent the personal side of mercy and empathy. His imprecations represent his appeal that justice prevail when malice persists. B. Sorrow Over Sinful Consequences Scripture portrays sin as destroying both the sinner and those around them. David’s grief demonstrates how he recognizes the tragedy of fallen behavior. Isaiah 59:2 teaches that sin separates people from God. David laments over his enemies partly because he sees the inevitable outcome if they continue in their ways. C. Love Righteousness, Hate Wickedness Psalm 45:7 declares, “You have loved righteousness and hated wickedness”. David’s life, including his psalms, reflects this principle. Loving righteousness means having compassion on people (made in God’s image). Hating wickedness means longing for God to remove evil from the community. This dual response—compassion for the person, rejection of the sin—helps explain David’s posture. 5. Broader Scriptural Corroboration The principle of loving one’s enemies and at the same time desiring God’s justice spans the entirety of Scripture: • Examples in the Old Testament: Individuals like Moses, Jeremiah, and Nehemiah prayed for Israel while pronouncing judgment on wickedness. • New Testament Fulfillment: When Jesus says, “Love your enemies and pray for those who persecute you” (Matthew 5:44), He was not undoing the concept of divine judgment but highlighting personal kindness. • Apocalyptic Writings: The Book of Revelation portrays believers crying out for vindication (Revelation 6:10) while the gospel invites repentance, echoing the same dual tension of mercy and judgment. Archaeological research from Tel Dan and other ancient sites attests to the historical veracity of David’s era, while the Dead Sea Scrolls confirm that such petitions and praises have been preserved faithfully. This textual reliability supports that the biblical record conveys precisely how David felt and prayed, in a manner that remains instructive for readers today. 6. Pastoral and Behavioral Implications When facing hostility, it is natural to be torn between compassion for those who harm us and an appeal to a higher authority to intervene. David’s example offers guidance: • Maintain a Heart of Compassion: Praying for others, even those who wrong us, guards against personal bitterness. • Seek Divine Justice Rather Than Personal Vengeance: We can entrust our cause to God, confident He will do what is right. • Stay Grounded in Truth: Balancing empathy and truth demands that we not condone evil behavior but also that we not harbor malice or hatred in our hearts. From a behavioral science perspective, righteous indignation is healthiest when guided by objective, divine standards rather than personal vendettas. This ensures that anger does not degenerate into destructive bitterness but remains a propelling force toward justice and restoration. 7. Conclusion David intercedes in heartfelt mourning for his foes when they suffer, yet he also calls for God’s righteous judgment upon them when they persist in wickedness. Rather than a contradiction, Psalm 35:13–14 exemplifies the simultaneous realities of compassion for fellow human beings and an unwavering commitment to seeing God’s justice prevail. By grieving over his enemies’ plight, David demonstrates a loving spirit. By asking God to intervene against persistent evil, he shows reverence for divine righteousness. The outcome is a unified portrayal of someone who yearns for repentance and restoration but also acknowledges that God’s holy judgment is necessary if sin remains unrepentant. This dual stance resonates throughout Scripture, reminding believers that both mercy and justice originate in the same God who loves righteousness and opposes evil. |
    |