Is selling in church inappropriate? I. Introduction In discussing whether selling in church is appropriate, many turn to accounts where Jesus took strong action against commerce in the temple. Though examples from Scripture address specific historical contexts, these principles shed light on how believers might regard trading or fundraising within places of worship today. Understanding these biblical passages provides valuable insight into what is or isn’t permissible in church gatherings. II. Biblical Accounts of Commerce in the Temple 1. Jesus Clears the Temple in the Gospels One of the most well-known accounts appears in all four Gospels, such as John 2:13–17. According to the Berean Standard Bible, “When it was almost time for the Jewish Passover, Jesus went up to Jerusalem. In the temple courts He found men selling cattle, sheep, and doves, and money changers seated at their tables… So He made a whip of cords and drove all from the temple courts…” (John 2:13–15). Matthew recounts a similar scene: “Jesus entered the temple courts and drove out all who were buying and selling there. He overturned the tables of the money changers and the seats of those selling doves. And He declared to them, ‘It is written: “My house will be called a house of prayer.” But you are making it a den of robbers!’” (Matthew 21:12–13). Similar passages occur in Mark 11:15–17 and Luke 19:45–46. In each instance, Jesus’ primary concern is that the temple, designed as a dedicated house of prayer, has become overshadowed by profit-seeking vendors taking advantage of worshippers. The issue is not only the buying and selling itself, but the exploitative nature, the loss of reverence, and the commercialization of holy space. 2. The Old Testament Context Under the Old Covenant, worshippers traveling to Jerusalem were expected to present sacrifices (Deuteronomy 12:5–7; 16:16–17). Commerce in or near the temple precincts developed partly to meet this need. Over time, however, the temple precinct became overly commercialized. Archaeological findings and historical writings (including references found in Josephus’s works) confirm the presence of money-changers in the Court of the Gentiles, where foreign coins were exchanged for the local currency required to pay the temple tax. These operations became lucrative businesses rather than simple services for travelers. Scripture addresses the attitude of the heart during worship (Psalm 51:16–17). The sacrificial system was never meant to be exploited for financial gain. Instead, sacrifices were an act of devotion to God, never intended as an avenue for predatory commerce. III. The Broader Principle of Reverence 1. Setting Apart Holy Space for Worship In the New Testament, believers are taught to respect God’s dwelling place. While the physical temple was central under the Old Covenant, the church gathering today is likewise a place to bring collective devotion to God (Hebrews 10:24–25). As Scripture says, “For where two or three gather together in My name, there am I with them” (Matthew 18:20). Reverence is crucial, just as it was in the original temple precincts. 2. Heart Attitude in Worship Selling in church is not automatically wrong if aimed at supporting ministry or charitable causes with transparency. The underlying issue in Jesus’ confrontation was exploitative, self-enriching commerce overshadowing reverence. Paul writes that whatever believers do should be done “for the glory of God” (1 Corinthians 10:31). If any transaction detracts from that purpose—distracting people from worship or taking advantage of them—Scripture’s cautionary examples apply. IV. Historical and Practical Concerns 1. Historical Misuse of Church as Marketplace Historically, from the medieval era onward, wealthy individuals or organizations sometimes targeted congregants for profit under the guise of religious donations or sales. While raising needed resources for ministry can be honorable, exploitation in a church setting has been condemned by many reform movements and recognized as unscriptural. 2. Today’s Practice and Discernment Modern examples might include sales for missions fundraisers, church bookstores, coffee stations, or materials for Bible study. The question is whether these activities occur ethically, in a designated area, and with hearts dedicated to serving rather than merely making money. Church leaders often decide on clear guidelines that maintain an atmosphere of respect. V. Guidelines and Application 1. Maintain a Worshipful Environment Ensure that activities inside the main worship area adhere to the principle of reverence (John 2:16). Initiatives for generating funds—like selling resources—are typically best positioned where they will not distract from worship. If it becomes a loud marketplace, resembling the money-changers in the temple courts, biblical precedent warns against continuing. 2. Promote Fair Practices If fundraising is conducted, there should be openness and integrity. Titus 1:7 sets high ethical standards for church leaders to be above reproach in handling material matters. Transparency, fair pricing, and ensuring money is used for God-honoring ministry safeguard against the exploitative practices Christ condemned. 3. Honor God With All Commerce When commerce occurs among believers, Paul’s counsel in Romans 12:10—to “love one another with brotherly affection”—reminds the church to prioritize the welfare of others above self. This principle, combined with devotion to God’s glory (1 Corinthians 10:31), can transform even simple transactions into opportunities for fellowship and service rather than material gain. VI. Conclusion Selling in church is not inherently inappropriate when approached with reverence, honesty, and a heart focused on worship. Scripture’s condemnation centers on exploitative or irreverent commerce that disregards the sanctity of God’s house. In applying biblical principles, churches can carefully discern how to handle sales or fundraisers in a way that keeps Christ at the center, safeguards a worshipful environment, and serves the needs of the faith community. By honoring God, maintaining integrity, and remembering that the primary purpose of gathering is to worship and glorify Him, believers can ensure any transactions within the church context align with the spirit of Scripture. |
    |