What are Sides A, B, X, and Y? 1. Overview of Terminology In various discussions related to Christian teachings on human sexuality, one encounters the designations “Side A,” “Side B,” “Side X,” and “Side Y.” Although these labels do not appear in Scripture itself, they have become a shorthand in modern discourse for describing positions on how followers of Christ should understand and respond to same-sex attraction. Below is a comprehensive look at what each side represents, how these approaches developed, and how they are discussed in light of Scripture and broader historical and theological considerations. 2. Historical and Cultural Emergence of the Terms Over the past several decades, numerous Christian communities have debated questions of sexuality and identity. In an effort to distinguish differing viewpoints, the designations “A,” “B,” “X,” and “Y” emerged primarily through online forums, church discussions, and academic writings. They are not official categories adopted by any particular denomination but rather descriptors adopted by individuals and groups attempting to summarize various stances. Early references to “Side A” and “Side B” appeared in published materials discussing whether same-sex relationships could be consistent with Christian faith. Later, “Side X” and “Side Y” were introduced to identify additional nuances in belief and practice. Although some writers and ministries use slightly different terminology or emphasize distinct aspects, the following explanations capture each position’s general scope. 3. Defining Side A 3.1 Core Claim Side A adherents hold that loving, committed same-sex relationships can be affirmed within a Christian framework. They argue that the biblical references to same-sex conduct typically address exploitative or idolatrous circumstances rather than consensual, covenant-based unions. Proponents often interpret related injunctions (e.g., Romans 1:26–27) as culturally specific or context-bound. 3.2 Scriptural Arguments and Counterarguments Side A interpreters point to the love and fidelity described in passages such as John 13:34 (BSB: “A new commandment I give you: Love one another. As I have loved you, so you also must love one another.”) to advocate that faithful same-sex unions fulfill the broader law of love. They emphasize certain cultural contexts behind biblical passages that appear to forbid same-sex acts. Critics and alternative perspectives respond that primary biblical texts (e.g., Romans 1:26–27; 1 Corinthians 6:9–10) are unequivocal in describing same-sex acts as contrary to God’s design. The prevailing historical understanding of the church has consistently taught that marriage is solely the union of one man and one woman (cf. Genesis 2:23–24), and that sexual intimacy outside of this framework is sin. 4. Defining Side B 4.1 Core Claim Side B is characterized by the conviction that same-sex attraction, in and of itself, is not a deliberate sin but a reality of the fallen world; believers experiencing it are called to a life of chastity or celibacy if they remain exclusively attracted to the same sex. Therefore, one must remain faithful to biblical mandates regarding sexual ethics by refraining from same-sex sexual activity. 4.2 Scriptural Basis Side B believers often reference passages affirming God’s design for marriage as male and female (Matthew 19:4–5: “He answered, ‘Have you not read that from the beginning the Creator ‘made them male and female,’ and said, ‘For this reason a man will leave his father and mother and be united to his wife, and the two will become one flesh’?”). They also highlight that temptations themselves are not necessarily sinful, citing verses such as Hebrews 4:15, which notes that Christ was tempted yet without sin. 4.3 Practical Application Side B individuals and ministries focus on discipleship, spiritual community, and accountability, encouraging believers with same-sex attraction to cultivate robust friendships, serve in the church, and direct their relational energies toward the body of Christ. They hold that living celibately reflects obedience to God’s design, as expounded in Scripture. 5. Defining Side X 5.1 Core Claim Side X typically believes that same-sex attraction is something one should strive to leave behind (or at least greatly diminish) through spiritual, psychological, or therapeutic means. “Side X” is often associated with ex-gay movements that stress transformation of orientation, citing personal testimonies and certain biblical passages about sanctification and renewal. 5.2 Scriptural Support and Approaches Proponents highlight verses such as 1 Corinthians 6:9–11, noting that “some of you were” involved in various sins, but “you were washed… you were justified.” They infer from this that all aspects of prior sinful identity can be changed by the Holy Spirit’s power. Accordingly, they encourage active pursuit of healing or reorientation therapies under the conviction that the gospel not only forgives but can also transform one’s desires. 5.3 Points of Caution Critics point out situations where claims of complete orientation change can produce psychological conflicts. They also note that while the transformative power of God should never be underestimated, Scripture does not promise every believer will experience the removal of all temptations or desires—only that one can remain faithful and pure through the indwelling Holy Spirit. 6. Defining Side Y 6.1 Core Claim Side Y is a less common category encompassing those who emphasize identity in Christ above any label tied to orientation. While similar to Side B in its commitment to biblical boundaries for sexual ethics, Side Y often de-emphasizes the salience of orientation altogether. Individuals holding this view concentrate on holistic discipleship, personal growth, and fellowship rather than constant introspection over same-sex attraction. 6.2 Historical and Practical Context Side Y gathers insights from pastoral care, counseling, and spiritual formation, aiming to help believers view themselves primarily in terms of their union with Christ (cf. Galatians 2:20). They encourage adopting a broader perspective on personhood, community life, and mission, resisting cultural pressure to make one’s orientation a primary identifier. 7. Broader Theological and Philosophical Considerations 7.1 Creation Order A recurrent theme in every side’s discussion is the original design described in Genesis 1–2. In the Berean Standard Bible, Genesis 1:27 states, “So God created man in His own image; in the image of God He created him; male and female He created them.” This foundation is cited by many voices to underscore that the biological and relational interplay of male and female expresses God’s creative intent. 7.2 The Fall and Its Consequences Among all sides, there is a recognition (albeit expressed differently) that the world is fallen and that all people wrestle with brokenness. Passages like Romans 3:23 (BSB: “for all have sinned and fall short of the glory of God”) and Romans 8:22 (BSB: “We know that the whole creation has been groaning together in the pains of childbirth until the present time”) provide perspective on why pain, confusion, and moral struggles persist, including in the realm of sexuality. 7.3 Redemption Through Christ No matter the position, Christians affirm only Christ’s redemptive work can reconcile us to God. As Paul declared in Romans 5:1: “Therefore, since we have been justified through faith, we have peace with God through our Lord Jesus Christ.” Scripture calls believers to surrender every aspect of life (1 Thessalonians 5:23–24) to the lordship of Christ. The conversation around “Sides” tries to navigate how best to do so regarding sexuality. 8. Pastoral Care and Community Life 8.1 The Role of Fellowship Church communities play a vital role in supporting individuals personally and spiritually. Whether individuals align with Side A, B, X, or Y, a local church—guided by Scripture and overflowing with mercy—provides discipleship programs, small groups, and mentorship to encourage believers in living out a Christ-honoring life. 8.2 Balancing Grace and Truth Congregations often face the challenge of balancing biblical fidelity with compassionate care. Paul’s instruction in Ephesians 4:15 to “speak the truth in love” remains a guiding principle. Engaging with genuine humility, listening well, and showing palpable kindness affirm the dignity of each person while not diminishing scriptural teachings. 9. Key Scriptural Passages • Genesis 1:27–28 – God’s creation of humanity as male and female • Genesis 2:24 – “For this reason a man will leave his father and mother and be united to his wife…” • Romans 1:26–27 – Paul’s mention of same-sex relations in the context of humanity’s rebellion • 1 Corinthians 6:9–11 – Noting certain practices, including same-sex acts, were part of believers’ past • Matthew 19:4–5 – Jesus reaffirming the male-female framework of marriage • Ephesians 4:15 – Command to speak truth in love 10. Relevant Historical, Archeological, and Scholarly Voices • Early Church Writings: While not labeling positions “A,” “B,” “X,” or “Y,” several of the earliest Christian teachers (e.g., Clement of Alexandria, Tertullian) emphasized sexual holiness tied to a male-female understanding of marriage. • Contemporary Scholarship: Works by biblical experts who rely on extensive manuscript evidence point to consistent teaching throughout Scripture on the nature of marriage and sexuality. Such manuscripts include the Chester Beatty Papyri and Codex Sinaiticus, which preserve passages relevant to this discussion. • Sociological Perspectives: Behavioral science data highlight that personal identity formation is complex. Individuals from different “Sides” point to anecdotal and scientific findings—such as studies of sexual identity development—to underscore their respective approaches. 11. Summary and Conclusion In modern discourse, “Side A” affirms same-sex relationships as potentially compatible with Christian teaching, while “Side B” sees the orientation as not chosen but calls for celibate faithfulness. “Side X” focuses on seeking transformation of orientation or a departure from same-sex attraction, and “Side Y” emphasizes identity in Christ above categorizing orientation. For anyone examining these perspectives, Scripture remains pivotal: “Your word is a lamp to my feet and a light to my path” (Psalm 119:105). Disagreements often hinge on different interpretations of key texts, the role of historical context, and the extent of transformation or sanctification in the believer’s life. Whatever one’s position may be, believers are exhorted to seek faithfulness, love, and truth, relying on the instruction of the Holy Spirit, the fellowship of the church, and the unchanging word of God. |
    |