If God is perfectly just, why does He forgive some sinners but not others? Understanding the Question Why does a perfectly just God forgive some sinners while not extending the same forgiveness to others? This question arises from both a moral concern (about God’s fairness) and a theological concern (about how salvation truly works). The Bible consistently addresses God’s combination of perfect justice and deep mercy. Below is an in-depth exploration, drawing from Scripture as the final authority (all quotations are from the Berean Standard Bible), along with historical, philosophical, and archaeological insights that support the integrity of the biblical testimony. 1. God’s Perfect Justice in Scripture The Bible asserts that God’s justice is unimpeachable and unchanging: • Psalm 89:14: “Righteousness and justice are the foundation of Your throne.” • Deuteronomy 32:4: “He is the Rock, His work is perfect; all His ways are just.” From the earliest portions of Scripture, God is recognized as Judge of all the earth (Genesis 18:25), and this role includes holding humanity accountable for sin. Yet the same passages also describe His mercy, offering sinners the potential for restoration if they turn back to Him. God’s justice ensures that sin cannot go unpunished: “The wages of sin is death” (Romans 6:23). At the same time, He provides a path for forgiveness. Because He is perfectly just, He cannot simply ignore iniquity; instead, He balances His justice with a merciful offer of redemption. 2. The Condition of Sin and the Need for Forgiveness Scripture clearly states that all humanity is under sin: • Romans 3:23: “For all have sinned and fall short of the glory of God.” Since every person stands guilty before a just God, the question becomes why some find forgiveness while others do not. The distinction made in Scripture is not that certain people are less sinful, but rather that some respond to God’s offer of forgiveness, while others harden their hearts. In biblical narrative, those who humbly acknowledge their wrongdoing and turn to God in repentance receive mercy. Those who persist in rebellion and reject God’s gracious provision remain under judgment. This principle is woven throughout the Old and New Testaments. 3. The Basis of Forgiveness: Repentance and Faith A key aspect the Bible emphasizes is genuine repentance—turning away from sin—and faith in God’s promise of salvation: • Acts 3:19: “Repent, then, and turn back, so that your sins may be wiped away.” • Ephesians 2:8–9: “For it is by grace you have been saved through faith, and this not from yourselves; it is the gift of God, not by works, so that no one can boast.” God’s standard for forgiveness is not partiality or favoritism; He calls “all men everywhere to repent” (Acts 17:30). Those who respond in penitence and trust in Christ become reconciled to God. Those who refuse remain outside forgiveness, not because God’s mercy is lacking, but because His gift is resisted. 4. The Role of Free Will The Bible portrays human beings as morally responsible agents capable of responding to or rejecting God’s grace. Passages such as Joshua 24:15 apply this principle: “Choose for yourselves this day whom you will serve.” Forgiveness is extended to all who will accept it on God’s terms, but free will means people can reject that offer. In this sense, God’s backbone of justice remains consistent, while His mercy is extended to those who accept His invitation. 5. God’s Justice Demonstrated in Creation and History From the earliest recorded history, there is a consistent biblical claim that God created the universe with order and moral responsibility (Genesis 1:1). Historical evidences—including archaeological discoveries at ancient city sites like the ruins of Jericho—have affirmed the authenticity of many biblical accounts where God judged or delivered people based on their receptivity to His commands. • Archaeologists John Garstang and Kathleen Kenyon’s studies at Jericho provided data that align with the biblical timeframe of a sudden collapse of the city walls (Joshua 6). Though scholarly debates continue, these findings have been cited as possible corroboration of a historical event in which God judged a sinful city and delivered Israel. • Likewise, the discovery of the Dead Sea Scrolls in the 20th century provided evidence of the remarkable textual consistency of the Old Testament, showing that God’s standard of righteousness and justice has been preserved over centuries. 6. Divine Mercy and the Offer of Salvation Despite humanity’s guilt, the Bible underscores that God “is patient with you, not wanting anyone to perish, but everyone to come to repentance” (2 Peter 3:9). He provides the means of salvation in Christ: • John 3:16–17: “For God so loved the world that He gave His one and only Son, that everyone who believes in Him shall not perish but have eternal life. For God did not send His Son into the world to condemn the world, but to save the world through Him.” In the biblical worldview, forgiveness is offered through the work of Christ on the cross. God remains perfectly just because Christ absorbs the penalty of sin for those who turn to Him. God remains perfectly merciful because He offers this salvation to any who will receive it. 7. God’s Justice and Mercy Displayed in the Cross At the apex of the biblical narrative stands the crucifixion and resurrection of Jesus Christ. This is not only the core of Christian theology but also a pivotal event in history: • Romans 5:8–9: “But God proves His love for us in this: While we were still sinners, Christ died for us. Therefore, since we have now been justified by His blood, how much more shall we be saved from wrath through Him!” There is substantial manuscript evidence—more than 5,800 Greek New Testament manuscripts, plus early translations—that attests to the reliability of the texts describing Christ’s death and resurrection. Ancient secular historians (e.g., Josephus, Tacitus) also reference the existence of Christians worshiping a resurrected Messiah early in the first century. These historical and textual confirmations lend credence to the claim that Christ’s death was a real event, fulfilling the requirement of God’s justice, and offering a forgiveness that, because of Christ’s substitutionary sacrifice, does not violate God’s perfect standard. 8. Why Some Sinners Are Forgiven and Others Are Not In summary of biblical teaching: 1. All people sin and deserve God’s just punishment (Romans 3:23; 6:23). 2. God’s mercy extends a genuine offer of forgiveness through Christ (John 3:16). 3. Those who repent and place their faith in Christ receive forgiveness, as the penalty for their sin is accounted for by Jesus’s sacrifice (1 John 1:9). 4. Those who reject this offer remain under their own guilt (John 3:36). God does not forgive arbitrarily; He forgives according to whether individuals accept or reject His provided means of salvation. It is not a matter of favoritism or selective justice, but a matter of whether a person surrenders to God’s plan of redemption in Christ. 9. Philosophical and Behavioral Dimensions From a behavioral standpoint, true repentance involves a heart transformation that realigns one’s will with God’s. This willingness to surrender and change is central to genuine forgiveness. Philosophically, if God simply overlooked sin, He would no longer be just. By making atonement available, He maintains both justice and mercy. This principle resonates with human intuition about fairness: We expect wrongdoing to be addressed, not ignored. The Bible teaches that God addresses wrongdoing at the cross of Christ—He fully upholds justice by judging sin, while fully expressing mercy by offering grace to those who will receive it. 10. Conclusion God remains perfectly just by demanding a fitting penalty for sin. He demonstrates unparalleled mercy by paying that penalty Himself through Christ’s sacrifice and resurrection. Scripture repeatedly teaches that God wants all to know His forgiveness. Yet He will never override free will. Those who yield to Him—admitting sin and trusting Christ—experience divine forgiveness that is grounded in the perfect justice of God. Those who persist in rejecting the gracious offer remain in their sin, awaiting judgment. This distinction ensures that God upholds both integrity and love. This principle reflects the harmony and coherence of biblical teaching, underscored by historical references, archaeological confirmations, and the consistent witness of manuscript evidence. It remains a profound invitation: Forgiveness is available, rooted in God’s perfect justice and mercy, and offered to all who call upon the name of the Lord (Romans 10:13). |
    |