Mark 2:5–7 – If only God can forgive sins, why does this passage seem to attribute God’s authority to Jesus without clearer proof of His divinity? I. The Context of Mark 2:5–7 Mark 2:5–7 states, “When Jesus saw their faith, He said to the paralytic, ‘Son, your sins are forgiven.’ But some of the scribes were sitting there and reasoning in their hearts, ‘Why does this man speak like this? He is blaspheming! Who can forgive sins but God alone?’” In this passage, a paralyzed man is brought to Jesus by four friends, who are so determined to get him help that they remove part of the roof above where Jesus is speaking. Upon seeing their faith, Jesus declares the man’s sins forgiven, stirring controversy among the religious leaders who rightly affirm that only God has the authority to forgive sin. Their reaction sets the stage for understanding the larger theological claim: that Jesus not only acts with divine authority but also reveals His nature through the forgiveness of sin and the subsequent healing. II. The Claim That Only God Can Forgive Sins Throughout the Hebrew Scriptures, sin is primarily pictured as an affront against God. Passages such as Isaiah 43:25 depict God declaring, “I, yes I, am He who blots out your transgressions for My own sake and remembers your sins no more.” Forgiveness of sins is always under the authority of Yahweh. Accordingly, when first-century Jewish religious leaders hear Jesus attributing that same authority to Himself, they suspect blasphemy (cf. Leviticus 24:16). They recognize the gravity of this claim and thus question how Jesus can speak and act in a manner that places Him on the same level as God. This sets up a clear theological tension: either Jesus is truly God and therefore has the right to forgive sins, or He is committing grave blasphemy. III. Jesus Demonstrates Divine Authority 1. Healing as Visible Validation Immediately following verse 7, Jesus confirms His authority by healing the paralytic. Mark 2:9–11 records Him asking, “Which is easier: to say to the paralytic, ‘Your sins are forgiven,’ or to say, ‘Get up, pick up your mat, and walk’? But so that you may know that the Son of Man has authority on earth to forgive sins…” Jesus then heals the man physically. This miraculous act serves as tangible evidence that Jesus’s words of forgiveness are not empty. The same power that heals the body validates His power to forgive sin. While the scribes demand more proof, Jesus’s healing of the paralytic constitutes a direct, undeniable demonstration of divine authority. 2. The Title “Son of Man” Jesus often refers to Himself as the “Son of Man,” a title rooted in Daniel 7:13–14, which describes a figure receiving “authority, glory, and sovereign power” from the Ancient of Days. By choosing this messianic title, Jesus aligns Himself with the one who is granted all authority—an indication of His divine identity and role. 3. Supporting Passages in the Gospels The same authority to forgive sins is captured across the Gospel accounts. In Luke 7:48, Jesus tells a sinful woman, “Your sins are forgiven.” Similarly, in John 20:28, Thomas addresses Jesus as “My Lord and my God!” This broader scriptural harmony underscores that Jesus consistently acts and is proclaimed in a way that belongs uniquely to Yahweh. IV. Historical and Manuscript Support for Jesus’s Divine Claim 1. Early Manuscripts Ancient fragments such as Papyrus P45 and Codex Sinaiticus contain portions of Mark’s Gospel. Textual analysis shows remarkable consistency in the wording of Mark 2:5–7 across these manuscripts, demonstrating that the claim—Jesus explicitly forgiving sins—was not a later addition but an authentic component of the earliest records. 2. Writings of Early Church Fathers Second-century Church Fathers like Justin Martyr and Irenaeus reference Jesus’s miraculous works and His claims of deity. In their apologetic writings, they confirm that the early Christian community recognized Jesus’s authority to forgive sins, interpreting it as a direct assertion of His divine nature. 3. Archaeological Corroborations Archaeological studies in and around Capernaum (commonly identified as the setting for many of Jesus’s miracles in Mark) reveal a first-century Jewish village consistent with the Gospel accounts’ cultural and historical context. Findings such as the remnants of the ancient synagogue in Capernaum reinforce the reliability of Mark’s regional details, lending further credibility to the biblical narrative. V. The Unity of Scripture and the Divinity of Jesus 1. Consistency with Old Testament Prophecies The Hebrew Scriptures foretell that the Messiah will partake in works only God can do. Isaiah 35:5–6 expresses that in the Messianic age, “the eyes of the blind will be opened and the ears of the deaf unstopped. Then the lame will leap like a deer.” Jesus’s miracles—including the healing of paralysis in Mark 2—align precisely with these prophecies. 2. Jesus’s Power Over Sin as a Divine Prerogative From beginning to end, Scripture presents a coherent theology where sin is ultimately erased only by God’s power. Jesus’s action in Mark 2 stands in clear continuity with this overarching theme. Rather than diminishing God’s role, the account in Mark highlights that Jesus possesses the very authority of God. 3. Culmination in the Resurrection According to multiple Gospel accounts and the testimony of early disciples, Jesus’s resurrection stands as the greatest demonstration of His divine identity (cf. Romans 1:4). The resurrection, widely attested in historical and textual sources, vindicates the claim first made visible at the healing of the paralytic. If Jesus has power over death itself, then the authority displayed in Mark 2 is only one facet of His full divinity. VI. Addressing the Question of Clearer Proof The question arises: If only God can forgive sins, why does Mark 2:5–7 not present more explicit statements of Jesus’s divinity? Within the Gospel narrative, Jesus often reveals His divine nature progressively. His actions—healing the sick, bestowing forgiveness, and conquering death—speak volumes to His identity. Following the cultural and theological setting of His day, Jesus uses messianic titles, reveals Himself through wonders, and affirms the same prerogatives uniquely attributed to God. Rather than stating simply “I am God” in every encounter, He demonstrates it through fulfilling the works that only God can do. Mark 2:5–7 is thus a profound yet unfolding revelation of who Jesus is, confirmed ultimately by His resurrection. VII. Conclusion In Mark 2:5–7, the scribes’ challenge—“Who can forgive sins but God alone?”—highlights the very heart of the issue. Jesus’s pointed response and subsequent healing reveal that He holds the same authority as Yahweh. This dual manifestation of forgiving the man’s sins and restoring his physical health leads to the inescapable conclusion that Jesus is no mere teacher or prophet but the one in whom “the fullness of Deity dwells bodily” (cf. Colossians 2:9). Across the Gospels, in Old Testament prophecies, in manuscript evidence, and in the testimony of the early Church, we find a unified message: Jesus has the divine right to forgive sins because He is God incarnate. Mark’s point is brilliantly clear. Far from being “blasphemy,” Jesus’s words and actions confirm His identity as Lord, fulfilling the Scriptures and providing the only true assurance of forgiveness and salvation. |
    |