1 Sam 23:20: Human plans vs. God's will?
How does 1 Samuel 23:20 demonstrate reliance on human plans over God's will?

Setting the Scene

David has just rescued Keilah (1 Samuel 23:1-5), repeatedly consulting the LORD before every move. Saul, meanwhile, is bent on hunting David. Verse 19 tells us the Ziphites go to Saul, offering intelligence on David’s whereabouts.


The Key Verse

“Now, O king, come down whenever you desire, and we will deliver him into your hand.” (1 Samuel 23:20)


What the Ziphites Reveal About Human Planning

• “Whenever you desire” – the timing is left to Saul’s preference, not to God’s direction.

• “We will deliver him” – the confidence is in their own ability, resources, and strategy.

• No reference to prayer, prophecy, or divine approval; only political calculation and personal gain.

• They ignore the LORD’s earlier declarations that David is His anointed (1 Samuel 16:1-13).

• Their plan presumes success against one whom God has repeatedly protected.


Saul’s Reliance on Fleshly Strategies

• Saul has stopped seeking God’s counsel; he depends on informants, spies, and sheer force (contrast his earlier practice in 1 Samuel 14:36-37).

• His obsession blinds him to the LORD’s clear providence in David’s life (1 Samuel 18:12, 28-29).

• He trusts human promises—“we will deliver”—over God’s earlier word that the kingdom has been torn from him (1 Samuel 15:23-28).


Contrast: David’s Dependence on God

1 Samuel 23:2 – “David inquired of the LORD…”

1 Samuel 23:4 – “Once again David inquired of the LORD, and the LORD answered him.”

1 Samuel 23:9-12 – David uses the ephod to ask if Saul will come; God answers and David acts accordingly.

• David’s safety comes from divine guidance, not from his own scheming; he refuses to seize Saul when he has the chance (24:4-6; 26:9-11), demonstrating trust in God’s timing.


Supporting Scriptures on Trusting God over Human Plans

Proverbs 3:5-6 – “Trust in the LORD with all your heart and lean not on your own understanding…”

Psalm 20:7 – “Some trust in chariots and others in horses, but we trust in the name of the LORD our God.”

James 4:13-15 – A warning against business plans that ignore God’s sovereign will.

Isaiah 31:1 – “Woe to those who go down to Egypt for help… but do not look to the Holy One of Israel.”


Lessons for Today

• Human ingenuity, alliances, and timing can never override God’s decrees.

• Even religious people (Saul and the Ziphites were Israelites) can slide into godless pragmatism when ambition rules the heart.

• Continual consultation with God, as modeled by David, keeps plans aligned with divine purpose.

• Success promised by others is empty when it contradicts clear Scriptural revelation.

1 Samuel 23:20 stands as a vivid snapshot of people staking everything on their own schemes while ignoring the Author of history, and it reminds believers to ground every plan in humble, prayerful submission to God’s will.

What is the meaning of 1 Samuel 23:20?
Top of Page
Top of Page