1 Sam 28:11: Dangers of forbidden guidance?
How does 1 Samuel 28:11 illustrate the dangers of seeking forbidden spiritual guidance?

Context: Saul’s Desperation

Saul faces the Philistine army, feels abandoned, and receives no answer from the LORD (1 Samuel 28:5-6). Instead of repenting, he turns to a medium—the very practice he had outlawed (1 Samuel 28:3).


The Forbidden Request (1 Samuel 28:11)

“Then the woman asked, ‘Whom shall I bring up for you?’ ‘Bring up Samuel,’ he replied.”

– Saul knowingly asks for necromancy.

– The medium prepares to summon the dead, trespassing a line God had clearly drawn (Leviticus 19:31).


Dangers Illustrated in This Single Verse

– Rejection of God’s voice: When Saul stops listening to Scripture and prophets, he opens himself to counterfeit voices.

– Direct disobedience: Deuteronomy 18:10-12 calls consulting the dead “detestable.” Saul violates explicit law.

– Spiritual deception: The source behind forbidden practices is demonic (1 Colossians 10:20; 2 Corinthians 11:14).

– Hardened conscience: Earlier compromises snowball into bolder rebellion (James 1:15).

– Isolation from divine help: 1 Chronicles 10:13-14 links Saul’s death to this very act.


Ripple Effects in Saul’s Life—A Quick Trace

– Fear replaces faith (1 Samuel 28:5).

– Samuel’s message confirms impending judgment (1 Samuel 28:18-19).

– Battle defeat and suicide follow (1 Samuel 31:4).

– His dynasty ends, Israel suffers, and God’s name is dishonored.


God’s Consistent Warnings Elsewhere

Leviticus 20:6: “I will set My face against the person who turns to mediums… and cut him off.”

Isaiah 8:19: “Should not a people consult their God? Why consult the dead on behalf of the living?”

Galatians 5:19-20 lists “witchcraft” among works of the flesh that bar inheriting the kingdom.

Acts 19:18-19 shows new believers burning occult scrolls as proof of repentance.


Practical Takeaways for Today

– Refuse shortcuts: God speaks through His written Word (2 Titus 3:16-17) and the Holy Spirit (John 16:13).

– Discern every spiritual claim by Scripture (1 John 4:1).

– Replace fear-driven curiosity with trust in God’s sufficiency (Psalm 23:1).

– Break ties with any occult object, practice, or influence (2 Corinthians 6:14-18).


Summing Up

1 Samuel 28:11 captures the moment Saul crosses a forbidden line. By seeking guidance from the dead, he forfeits divine counsel, exposes himself to deception, and sets in motion his own downfall. Scripture’s clear message: seek the living God, never the forbidden realm of the dead.

What is the meaning of 1 Samuel 28:11?
Top of Page
Top of Page