How does Matthew 27:35 fulfill Old Testament prophecy? Matthew 27:35 “After they had crucified Him, they divided His garments among themselves by casting lots.” Immediate Narrative Setting Matthew records Roman executioners gambling for Jesus’ clothing moments after fastening Him to the cross. The evangelist adds no explanatory comment, assuming his Jewish-literate audience will recognize the scene as the long-promised fulfillment of a Davidic psalm. Primary Prophetic Text – Psalm 22:16-18 “For dogs surround me; a band of evildoers encircles me; they have pierced my hands and feet. I can count all my bones; they stare and gloat over me. They divide my garments among them and cast lots for my clothing.” 1. Lexical Identity • LXX Psalm 21:19 (22:18 MT) reads διέμερισαν τὰ ἱμάτιά μου ἑαυτοῖς καὶ ἐπὶ τὸν ἱματισμόν μου ἔβαλον κλῆρον – the exact Greek verbs Matthew employs (διεμερίσαντο … βάλλοντες κλῆρον). • The Hebrew נָשָׂא גָּדִיל וְעַל־לְבוּשִׁי יַפִּיל גֹּורָל shows the same two-part action: division plus lot-casting. 2. Dating Before Christ Psalm 22 appears in 1QHodayota and 4QPsᵃ from Qumran (c. 150–50 BC), demonstrating the text was fixed centuries prior to Jesus. 3. Narrative Coherence David voices deep suffering while remaining vindicated by God—an archetype ultimately realized in Messiah. Secondary Prophetic Strands 1. Isaiah 53:12 – “He poured out His life unto death and was numbered with the transgressors.” The sharing-out of garments marks Him as an executed criminal among criminals. 2. Psalm 69:4 & 21 – depicts unjust hatred and physical torment that dovetail with the crucifixion scene. 3. Zechariah 12:10 – “They will look on Me whom they have pierced.” Although Matthew references Zechariah explicitly only in 21:4-5, his crucifixion narrative assumes the larger cluster of “piercing” prophecies. Historical Specificity of Crucifixion Details • Psalm 22 foretells “pierced hands and feet” nearly a millennium before the Persians devised crucifixion (c. 6th century BC) and long before Rome perfected it. • Archaeological remains of the crucified Jew Yehohanan (Giv‘at ha-Mivtar, AD 1st century) verify nail placement matching the Psalmic description—an unwitting extra-biblical confirmation of the method Matthew describes. Division vs. Casting Lots – Why Both? Roman execution law (Digesta 48.20.6) allowed soldiers to claim the clothing of condemned men. A seamless tunic, however, would be ruined if torn, so soldiers cast lots for it (John 19:23-24). Outer pieces were simply divided. The Psalm’s two verbs and Matthew’s single sentence capture both actions precisely. Early Christian Apologetic Witness • Peter applies Psalm 22 language in Acts 2:30-31, arguing that David foresaw Christ. • Justin Martyr (Dial. with Trypho 97, AD 150) challenges Jewish interlocutors with the garment prophecy as indisputable evidence of Messiah fulfilled. Theological Significance 1. Messianic Identity – The precision of fulfillment authenticates Jesus as the promised Son of David and the suffering Servant. 2. Scriptural Infallibility – A prophecy written centuries earlier, preserved intact, and fulfilled publicly under Roman governance substantiates the Bible’s divine authorship. 3. Substitutionary Atonement – The psalm’s movement from agony to triumph prefigures resurrection, anchoring the believer’s salvation in a historically verified event. Practical Implications for the Reader Because God kept this minute prophetic detail, He can be trusted with the grand promise of redemption (Romans 8:32). Faith rests not on myth but on verifiable history; therefore, the appropriate human response is repentance and devotion to the risen Christ whose garments, once gambled away, now clothe believers in righteousness. |
    |