Ishmael: Human desires vs. God's promises?
How does Abraham's request for Ishmael reflect human desires versus God's promises?

Setting the Scene

- Twenty-four years have passed since God first promised Abraham a son (Genesis 12:2; 15:4).

- Abraham is now ninety-nine, Sarah eighty-nine (Genesis 17:1, 17).

- Ishmael, born through Hagar, is thirteen (Genesis 17:25).

- The promise of a son through Sarah still looks impossible from every human angle.


Abraham’s Heartfelt Plea

“ ‘O that Ishmael might live before You!’ ” (Genesis 17:18)

- A short sentence loaded with emotion—Abraham loves his firstborn.

- He is asking God to place the covenant blessing on the son he already has, not on a yet-unseen child.


Human Desires on Display

- Desire for immediate security: Ishmael is tangible, visible, already part of the family.

- Desire to spare Sarah and himself further waiting, disappointment, or embarrassment.

- Desire to preserve his own effort: Ishmael was conceived through a human solution to barrenness (Genesis 16:1-4).

- Desire for simplicity: redirecting God’s promise to Ishmael would avoid another miracle.


God’s Unfailing Promise

“ ‘No, but Sarah your wife will bear you a son, and you shall call his name Isaac. I will establish My covenant with him…’ ” (Genesis 17:19)

- God answers Abraham’s “O that Ishmael…” with a firm “No, but…,” reaffirming His original word.

- The covenant is not subject to human revision; it rests on God’s sovereign choice (Genesis 12:1-3; Romans 9:7-9).

- God still blesses Ishmael generously (Genesis 17:20), yet the covenant line remains with Isaac—showing grace without compromise.


Ishmael and Isaac: Flesh and Promise

- Ishmael: “born according to the flesh” (Galatians 4:23)—the result of human planning and effort.

- Isaac: “born through the promise” (Galatians 4:23)—the result of divine power alone (Romans 4:19-21).

- Both sons receive blessing, but only one carries the redemptive line that leads to Christ (Luke 3:34).


Lessons for Our Walk

• God’s promises stand even when we propose easier alternatives (Proverbs 19:21).

• Faith waits for the miracle child, not the manageable substitute (Psalm 27:14).

• Deep affection for a good thing (Ishmael) must not eclipse allegiance to God’s better thing (Isaac).

• God kindly hears our heartfelt pleas (“I have heard you,” Genesis 17:20) yet redirects us to His perfect plan.

• The flesh produces what can be seen quickly; the Spirit births what endures eternally (John 3:6).


Encouragement for Today

- When time drags and solutions appear, resist settling for Ishmael; cling to the promise of Isaac.

- Trust the God “who gives life to the dead and calls into being what does not yet exist” (Romans 4:17).

- His “No, but…” is never a rejection of us; it is a safeguard for the greater blessing He has ordained.

What is the meaning of Genesis 17:18?
Top of Page
Top of Page