How does John 19:14 align with the Synoptic Gospels' timeline of events? John 19:14 “Now it was the Preparation Day of the Passover; it was about the sixth hour. And he said to the Jews, ‘Here is your King!’ ” Synoptic Time Markers • Mark 15:25—“It was the third hour, and they crucified Him.” • Matthew 27:45; Luke 23:44—darkness “from the sixth hour until the ninth hour.” • Mark 15:42—“when evening was already approaching, because it was Preparation Day (that is, the day before the Sabbath) …” Perceived Difficulties 1. John seems to place Jesus before Pilate “about the sixth hour,” whereas Mark places the crucifixion at the “third hour.” 2. John calls the day “Preparation Day of the Passover,” suggesting crucifixion before the Passover meal, yet the Synoptics record Jesus’ last supper as a Passover meal (Matthew 26:17; Mark 14:12; Luke 22:7). Key Terms • “Preparation” (Greek paraskeuē): idiom for Friday, the day of preparation for the weekly Sabbath (confirmed by Josephus, Antiquities 16.163; and by Mark 15:42). • “Passover” (Pascha): in first-century usage often encompassed the entire festival week of Unleavened Bread (cf. Luke 22:1; Josephus, Wars 5.99). • “Sixth hour”: can follow (a) Jewish sunrise reckoning (≈ noon) or (b) Roman civil reckoning from midnight (≈ 6 a.m.). Harmonization Model 1. Roman Time in John, Jewish Time in Synoptics • John, writing for a broader Greco-Roman audience, regularly references Roman measurements (e.g., stadium distance in John 6:19). • Roman civil hours begin at midnight; “about the sixth hour” ≈ 06:00, fitting an early-morning trial before Pilate. • Mark’s “third hour” (≈ 09:00 Jewish time) places the crucifixion shortly afterward. The interval—Roman 06:00 to Jewish 09:00—allows for mocking, Via Dolorosa procession, and arrival at Golgotha. 2. “Preparation of the Passover” = Friday of Passover Week • John repeats the phrase twice more: 19:31 (“because it was Preparation Day”) and 19:42 (“because it was the Jewish day of Preparation”). Both verses clearly refer to the day before the Sabbath. • Philo (Special Laws 2.175) and rabbinic sources (m. Pes. 4:1) treat 14 Nisan and 15 Nisan as one festival; thus calling Friday the “Preparation of the Passover” is natural language during festival week. • The Synoptic “first day of Unleavened Bread” (Mark 14:12) is a Semitic idiom that includes 14 Nisan, the day the lambs are slain (cf. Exodus 12:6). Both John and the Synoptics, therefore, present Jesus dying on Friday within the Passover feast framework. 3. Calendar Diversity Hypothesis (Galilean vs. Judean) • Some Galileans reckoned days sunrise-to-sunrise; Judeans, sunset-to-sunset (m. Hagigah 2:4). • If Jesus (a Galilean) ate the lamb after sunset of 13 Nisan (Galilean 14 Nisan), and Judeans slaughtered theirs the next afternoon (Judean 14 Nisan), both narratives stand without conflict. • This explains how the temple priests could still be concerned about defilement (John 18:28) while Jesus and His disciples had already eaten (Synoptics). 4. Textual Integrity • Papyrus 66 (c. A.D. 200) and Papyrus 75 (early III cent.) both read “about the sixth hour,” attesting to an early, uncontested text. • No variant manuscripts place John’s event at the third hour, indicating scribes saw no contradiction needing correction—a strong internal witness to harmonization. Archaeological & Historical Corroboration • Pilate’s inscription fragments from Caesarea (discovered 1961) confirm his prefecture when Passover crowds swelled Jerusalem, matching the Gospels’ timeframe. • The southern steps excavation shows mikva’ot used for festival purification, explaining John 18:28’s priestly concern. • Dead Sea Scroll calendrical texts (e.g., 4QCalendrical Doc) demonstrate existence of multiple Passover calculation methods in the Second Temple era. Theological Significance • John’s timing underscores Jesus as the true Passover Lamb—slain while temple lambs were being slaughtered (1 Corinthians 5:7). • Synoptic emphasis on covenant meal highlights the inaugurated New Covenant (Luke 22:20). Both perspectives converge: the Lamb is offered, and the covenant confirmed, on the same historical Friday that precedes the Sabbath. Practical Implications Scripture’s harmony under close examination strengthens confidence that every detail is trustworthy. Differences are complementary, not contradictory, providing a fuller tapestry of the Passion’s chronology and meaning. Summary When John’s Roman hour and broader festival vocabulary are recognized, his account dovetails precisely with the Synoptic timeline: an early-morning sentencing (≈ 06:00), crucifixion at ≈ 09:00, darkness at noon, death by ≈ 15:00, all on Friday of Passover week, the eve of the Sabbath. Thus John 19:14 aligns seamlessly with Matthew, Mark, and Luke, preserving historical accuracy and amplifying the redemptive purpose of Christ’s death. |
    |