How does John 5:47 challenge the authority of Moses' writings in understanding Jesus' message? JOHN 5:47 AND THE AUTHORITY OF MOSES’ WRITINGS Canonical Setting John 5 narrates Jesus’ healing of the lame man at Bethesda, His claim to divine prerogatives, and His courtroom-style confrontation with the Judean leadership. The climactic indictment is John 5:46-47 : “For if you had believed Moses, you would believe Me, because he wrote about Me. 47 But since you do not believe what he wrote, how will you believe what I say?” The verse anchors Jesus’ entire self-revelation to the Pentateuch, making acceptance of Moses the gateway to understanding Christ. Mosaic Witness to the Messiah 1. Genesis 3:15 – promised Seed who crushes the serpent. 2. Genesis 22:8,14 – substitutionary ram; “on the mount of the LORD it will be provided.” 3. Genesis 49:10 – Shiloh from Judah to whom obedience belongs. 4. Exodus 12 – Passover lamb typology (1 Corinthians 5:7). 5. Leviticus 16 – Day of Atonement prefiguring a once-for-all sacrifice (Hebrews 9:11-14). 6. Numbers 21:8-9 – bronze serpent, explicitly applied by Jesus to His cross (John 3:14-15). 7. Deuteronomy 18:15-18 – “prophet like me” whom the people must obey, quoted in Acts 3:22-23. Jesus asserts that these strands converge on Himself; rejecting them sabotages comprehension of His mission. Theological Implication: Continuity, Not Competition John 5:47 does not pit Christ against Moses; it binds them. Moses’ authority is upheld as foundational, while Christ is its telos (Romans 10:4). The challenge is directed at the audience’s unbelief, not at Mosaic credibility. Hermeneutical Principle Scripture interprets Scripture. Acceptance of earlier revelation conditions reception of later revelation. Jesus models a literal-historical reading of Torah events (creation, manna, serpent, Passover) and expects His hearers to do likewise. Philosophical and Behavioral Dimension Unbelief is not merely intellectual but moral (John 3:19-20). Rejecting Moses’ ethical demands (e.g., Deuteronomy 6:5; Leviticus 19:18) predisposes the heart against the One who perfectly embodies them. Hence John 5:47 diagnoses a volitional barrier: “You are unwilling to come to Me to have life” (John 5:40). Practical Implications for Evangelism and Discipleship 1. Ground seekers in the historicity of Genesis-Deuteronomy; it prepares them for the gospel. 2. Use fulfilled prophecy in Torah as evidential bridge to Christ. 3. Highlight the unity of Scripture—the same God speaks in both Testaments. 4. Call for a holistic faith: accepting the written Word and the living Word together. Conclusion John 5:47 challenges any attempt to segment or demote the Pentateuch. Jesus stakes His credibility on Moses’ writings; to dismiss the latter is to forfeit the former. Therefore, the path to grasping Jesus’ message necessarily runs through confident trust in the Mosaic Scriptures He affirmed, fulfilled, and illuminated. |
    |