How does Romans 5:14 explain the concept of original sin before the law was given? Full Text and Canonical Setting “Nevertheless death reigned from Adam until Moses, even over those who did not sin in the likeness of Adam’s transgression, who is a pattern of the One to come.” The verse sits inside the extended argument of Romans 5:12-21, which contrasts the universal effects of Adam’s disobedience with the universal remedy accomplished by Christ. Immediate Context: Death as Proof of Universal Sin Verses 12-13 declare that “sin entered the world through one man, and death through sin, and in this way death came to all men, because all sinned.” Before Sinai, no written code defined crimes as “transgression,” yet people still died. Paul’s logic is straightforward: physical death is a courtroom exhibit demonstrating that all humans bear guilt inherited from Adam. If a statute were required to make sin culpable, pre-Mosaic humanity would have been exempt from death. They were not—therefore guilt is deeper than written legislation. Original Sin Defined A two-fold inheritance: 1. Imputed Guilt: Adam, as covenant head, legally implicated all descendants (cf. 1 Corinthians 15:22). 2. Inherited Corruption: a bent toward self-rule (“the flesh,” Romans 7:18). Romans 5:14 treats both. Death is the legal penalty, while pervasive mortality evidences innate corruption. From Adam to Moses: A Timeline of Approximately 2500 Years Using a straightforward reading of Genesis genealogies (cf. Ussher), humanity spans: • Adam → Noah: c. 1656 AM (Anno Mundi) • Post-Flood → Abraham: c. 2008 AM • Abraham → Moses: c. 2513 AM In these centuries, divine judgments (Flood, Babel, Sodom) authenticate that moral accountability existed without Sinai’s tablets. Law Written on the Heart Romans 2:14-15 affirms an internal moral compass (“work of the Law written in their hearts”). Cross-cultural behavioral research corroborates shared moral intuitions—prohibitions of murder, theft, and perjury appear in the Lipit-Ishtar, Code of Hammurabi, Hittite laws, and Chinese bamboo legal strips. This moral convergence echoes Paul’s assertion that conscience renders every mouth “without excuse” (Romans 3:19). Death Reigned: Empirical Confirmation 1. Anthropology: Neolithic burial sites (e.g., Jericho, Göbekli Tepe) reveal universal human expectation of mortality. 2. Behavior Science: Terror Management Theory documents the psychological impact of death awareness, aligning with Hebrews 2:15 (“held in slavery by their fear of death”). 3. Young-Earth Geology: Polystrate fossilized tree trunks bridging multiple sediment layers—found in the Joggins Formation, Nova Scotia—demonstrate rapid burial conditions consistent with a post-Fall, post-Flood catastrophe, not an old-earth slow death cycle preceding sin. Adam as the Prototype, Christ as the Antitype Paul’s typology rests on representation: • Adam: One act → condemnation → death to all. • Christ: One act → justification → life to all who believe (Romans 5:18-19). Thus Romans 5:14 not only explains guilt before Mosaic Law but also sets the stage for grace preceding personal merit (Romans 5:8). Early Christian Reception Irenaeus, Against Heresies 3.18.1: “As death was established over those even who had not sinned after the likeness of Adam, so did life come through Him who obeyed, to all who from Him are born again.” Augustine, Enchiridion 26: cites Romans 5:14 to defend infant baptism, recognizing guilt prior to volitional sin. Common Objections Answered 1. “Unfair to inherit guilt.” Federal representation pervades daily life: diplomats, parents, even genetic inheritance. Scripture reveals the same structure in redemption—Christ bears guilt not His own (2 Corinthians 5:21). 2. “Babies die yet never choose sin.” Adamic guilt explains infant mortality while offering hope: David’s confidence regarding his deceased child (2 Samuel 12:23) presupposes God’s mercy grounded in the covenant of grace. Practical Implications • Evangelism: Universal death certifies universal need for the gospel. • Ethics: Recognizing inherited corruption fosters humility and dependence on the Spirit (Galatians 5:16-17). • Worship: Gratitude that grace precedes Law mirrors the chronology—God provided a Redeemer (Genesis 3:15) long before Sinai. Conclusion Romans 5:14 teaches that sin’s dominion predates Moses because humanity’s representative, Adam, plunged all into guilt and corruption. Death’s uninterrupted reign supplies the evidence; conscience supplies corroboration; archaeology, anthropology, and young-earth geology supply supporting illustrations. The verse thus magnifies Christ, the second Adam, whose resurrection secures deliverance from the universal predicament established “from Adam until Moses.” |
    |