Who is the "servant" referred to in Isaiah 42:19? Key Verse (Isaiah 42:19) “Who is blind but My servant, or deaf like the messenger I send? Who is blind like My dedicated one, or blind like the servant of the LORD?” Immediate Literary Setting Isaiah 42:18–25 forms a sharp contrast to 42:1–9. In 42:1–9 the Servant is depicted as Spirit-filled, gentle, justice-bringing. In 42:18–25 God suddenly laments that this same “servant” is blind and deaf. The shift is deliberate: Isaiah is using one title for two groups—the nation (corporate servant) and the coming Messiah (ideal Servant)—to expose Israel’s failure and introduce the One who will succeed where the nation has not. Isaiah’s Servant Corpus 1. 41:8-9 – Israel, the chosen servant 2. 42:1-9 – Spirit-anointed Messianic Servant 3. 42:18-25 – Israel, blind and deaf servant 4. 49:1-7 – Servant who regathers Israel yet is called “Israel” 5. 50:4-11 – Obedient, suffering Servant 6. 52:13—53:12 – Substitutionary, atoning Servant The pattern interweaves a corporate servant (national Israel) with an individual Servant (Messiah). Isaiah 42:19 clearly belongs to the corporate strand. Israel as the Blind and Deaf Servant • Isaiah repeatedly labels national Israel “blind” and “deaf” (cf. 6:9-10; 29:18; 32:3; 43:8). • The blindness is moral and covenantal, not physical—they have eyes and ears yet refuse God’s revelation (42:20). • Yahweh had given Israel unparalleled light (law, prophets, miracles), therefore their culpability is heightened (42:21). • Divine discipline through exile (42:24-25) vindicates God’s justice and displays the necessity of a righteous substitute. Messianic Servant Foreshadowed Even while indicting Israel, Isaiah keeps the Messianic Servant in view. The righteous Servant (42:1-4) will open blind eyes (42:7) for the blind servant (42:19). Thus the corporate servant’s deficiency magnifies the need for the ideal Servant, fulfilled in Jesus. Exegetical Notes • “Servant” (ʿebed) in Isaiah is a flexible term rooted in covenant vocation. • Hebrew word order in v. 19 piles up synonyms (blind/deaf) for emphasis. • “Messenger I send” (malʾāk) alludes to Israel’s mediatorial role among the nations (Exodus 19:6), now failed. Canonical Cross-References • Israel’s vocation: Exodus 19:5-6; Deuteronomy 4:6-8. • National blindness: Deuteronomy 29:4; Romans 11:7-10. • Messianic opening of eyes: Isaiah 35:5; Luke 4:18; John 9. New Testament Confirmation Matthew 12:18-21 quotes Isaiah 42:1-4 and applies it to Jesus, explicitly identifying Him as the righteous Servant. Later, Paul cites Israel’s blindness (Romans 11:25) and contrasts it with the enlightening work of Christ (2 Corinthians 4:4-6). The NT thus upholds the dual-servant framework: Israel blinded, Christ illuminating. Historical and Jewish Reception Early rabbinic sources (e.g., Targum Jonathan) read Isaiah 42:19 as Israel. Medieval Jewish commentators (Rashi, Ibn Ezra) concur. Yet some pre-Christian Jewish texts (e.g., 1 Enoch 48:10) anticipate an individual deliverer, showing that a Messianic reading was present within Judaism prior to the NT era. Patristic and Reformation Witness Church Fathers (Justin, Irenaeus, Augustine) harmonized the passages: Israel is the blind servant; Jesus is the saving Servant. Reformers (Calvin, Luther) retained the dual reference, underscoring God’s faithfulness to Israel and the sufficiency of Christ. Theological Implications 1. Human inability: Even God’s covenant people fail without regenerating grace. 2. Messianic necessity: Only the perfect Servant can fulfill Israel’s mission and atone for sin. 3. Missional continuity: Believers, now indwelt by the Spirit, are called to embody the Servant’s light to the nations (Acts 13:47). Practical Application • Self-examination: professing believers can repeat Israel’s pattern of possessing revelation yet ignoring it (James 1:22-25). • Evangelism: Isaiah 42 offers a bridge—human blindness meets divine illumination in Christ (John 8:12). • Hope for Israel: the prophecy anticipates national restoration (Isaiah 49:6; Romans 11:26). Summary Answer In Isaiah 42:19 the “servant” is national Israel, rebuked for spiritual blindness and deafness. Yet this negative portrait is deliberately set against the positive, Messianic Servant in 42:1-4, driving the reader to the ultimate Servant, Jesus Christ, who opens blind eyes and accomplishes the mission Israel could not fulfill. |
    |