Why couldn't the disciples cast out the demon in Luke 9:40? Setting the Scene On the heels of the Transfiguration, Jesus comes down the mountain (Luke 9:37-42). A desperate father meets Him in the crowd, explaining that a violent spirit is tormenting his only son. The father’s plea is heartbreaking: • “I begged Your disciples to drive it out, but they were unable.” (Luke 9:40) The Verse in Focus Luke pinpoints the moment of failure—an inability, not an unwillingness. Despite earlier victories, the Twelve are suddenly powerless. A Contrast: Authority Previously Given • “Jesus called the Twelve together and gave them power and authority over all demons and power to cure diseases.” (Luke 9:1-2) They had the authority. So what went wrong? Unpacking the Reasons for Failure • Lack of Faith – Jesus immediately diagnoses the deeper issue: “O unbelieving and perverse generation…” (Luke 9:41). – Matthew’s parallel is explicit: “Because you have so little faith.” (Matthew 17:20). – Faith is not mental assent but active reliance; their confidence had subtly shifted away from Christ to themselves. • Inadequate Dependence on Prayer (and Fasting) – Mark records the private debrief: “Why couldn’t we drive it out?” “This kind can come out only by prayer.” (Mark 9:28-29). – Some manuscripts include “and fasting,” underscoring spiritual preparation. The disciples apparently approached the crisis prayer-less, trying to repeat past methods rather than seek fresh power. • Possible Spiritual Pride and Distraction – Earlier success (Luke 9:6) may have bred complacency. – Right before this event they were arguing about who was greatest (Luke 9:46). A proud heart is spiritually powerless. • The Stubbornness of the Spirit Opposed – Jesus calls it “this kind,” hinting at varying intensity within demonic ranks (cf. Ephesians 6:12). Stronger opposition demands deeper dependence. Putting It Together The disciples failed not because authority had been revoked, but because faith was weak and prayer was absent. Authority without abiding dependence on Christ is empty (John 15:5). Take-Home Truths • Past victories never replace present faith. • Prayer is not optional maintenance; it is the power line. • Spiritual pride quietly turns authority into impotence. • Every encounter demands fresh reliance on Jesus, whose power alone routes the enemy. |
    |