Why could they not believe according to John 12:39? Contextual Setting (John 12:37–43) John reports that although Jesus “had performed so many signs in their presence, they still did not believe in Him” (John 12:37). Verse 38 cites Isaiah 53:1, and verses 39–40 cite Isaiah 6:10. Together these texts frame Israel’s unbelief as both foretold and judicially confirmed. John then writes, “For this reason they could not believe, because, as Isaiah says elsewhere: ‘He has blinded their eyes and hardened their hearts…’ ” (John 12:39–40). Divine Judicial Hardening 1. Old Testament Precedent. Isaiah’s call vision (Isaiah 6:1-13) describes God commissioning Isaiah to preach to a people who will, by divine decree, grow ever duller of hearing. The same pattern appears with Pharaoh (Exodus 4–14) where God repeatedly “hardens” (Heb. ḥāzaq) Pharaoh’s heart after Pharaoh first hardens his own (Exodus 8:15). 2. Purpose of Hardening. Hardening is not arbitrary; it serves redemptive ends—magnifying God’s glory (Romans 9:17), advancing salvation history (Romans 11:25), and setting a stage for Gentile inclusion (Isaiah 49:6; Acts 13:46-48). 3. Application in John. Israel’s leadership had already rejected clear revelation (John 5:39-47; 9:41). God’s act of hardening now “locks in” that rebellion, allowing the crucifixion (Acts 2:23) through which salvation comes (John 12:24, 32). Human Responsibility John balances divine sovereignty with human culpability: • Persistent Unbelief. The leaders “loved praise from men more than praise from God” (John 12:43). • Moral Choice. Earlier they had decided to expel confessors of Jesus from the synagogue (John 9:22), demonstrating a willful rejection. • Accountability. Jesus laments, “You refuse to come to Me to have life” (John 5:40). Refusal is theirs; incapacity is the result. The Isaiah Quotations Explained Isaiah 53:1 highlights disbelief in the Servant despite revelation. Isaiah 6:10 introduces the triplet “blind eyes… harden hearts… dull ears,” a formula reused in every Gospel and Acts. The Hebrew verb “to harden” (hāšaʿ) and Greek πωρόω (pōroō) both denote a calcifying process: repeated resistance becomes moral sclerosis. Progressive Paralysis of Unbelief Behavioral research confirms that entrenched bias, once reinforced, impairs later objectivity. Spiritual parallels abound: • 2 Thessalonians 2:11—God sends a “strong delusion” after prior rejection of truth. • Hebrews 3:13—Sin “hardens” through deceit. • Proverbs 29:1—A neck stiffened by many rebukes is “broken beyond remedy.” Divine Sovereignty and Compatibilism Scripture portrays God’s meticulous sovereignty (Proverbs 21:1; Ephesians 1:11) coexisting with authentic human choice (Deuteronomy 30:19; John 7:17). John’s Gospel insists on both: “No one can come to Me unless the Father draws him” (John 6:44), yet “everyone who believes… has eternal life” (6:47). The mystery lies not in contradiction but in concurrence: God ordains ends and means. Theological Implications 1. Necessity of Divine Illumination. Fallen humans are “dead” (Ephesians 2:1). New birth (John 3:3-8) is required for faith. 2. Sovereign Grace. While some are judicially hardened, others—like the crowd in Acts 2—are “cut to the heart” (Acts 2:37). Regeneration precedes responsive faith. 3. Missional Urgency. Hardening is neither universal nor permanent; Paul’s own conversion (Acts 9) proves God can reverse blindness (2 Corinthians 4:6). Archaeological Corroboration John’s Gospel situates events at verifiable locales: the Pool of Bethesda (John 5) excavated in 1888; the Stone Pavement (Gabbatha, John 19:13) identified beneath today’s Sisters of Zion convent. Such accuracy reinforces the text’s credibility when addressing hard-hearted unbelief. Pastoral and Evangelistic Application 1. Pray for Illumination. Since unbelief can harden, intercession seeks God’s mercy to “open their eyes” (Acts 26:18). 2. Present Clear Evidence. Jesus “did many signs,” and Christians today invoke historical, scientific, and experiential evidence to pierce skepticism. 3. Warn Lovingly. Hardened hearts risk irreversible judgment (John 3:36). Urgency tempers compassion (2 Corinthians 5:20). 4. Cultivate Humility. Believers recall that faith itself is a gift (Ephesians 2:8-9), fostering gratitude, not pride. Conclusion “They could not believe” because persistent, willful resistance triggered divine judicial hardening foretold by Isaiah, harmonizing God’s sovereignty with human responsibility. Isaiah’s prophecy, verified in history and manuscripts, underscores the gravity of rejecting revealed truth and the necessity of sovereign grace to awaken faith. |
    |