What is the significance of the three men meeting Saul in 1 Samuel 10:4? Canonical Text “Then you will go on from there until you reach the oak of Tabor. Three men going up to God at Bethel will meet you, one carrying three young goats, another carrying three loaves of bread, and the third carrying a skin of wine. They will greet you and give you two loaves of bread, which you will accept from their hands.” (1 Samuel 10:3-4) Immediate Context: A Prophetic Sign Sequence Samuel had just poured oil on Saul’s head, announcing, “Has not the LORD anointed you ruler over His inheritance?” (10:1). To anchor Saul’s faith, Samuel gives three precise signs (vv. 2-7). The meeting with the three pilgrims is sign #2. The accuracy of all three signs would prove that Samuel spoke for Yahweh and that Saul’s kingship was divinely authorized. Historical-Geographical Details The oak (or terebinth) of Tabor lay on the north–south ridge route that joins the Hill Country of Ephraim to Bethel. Modern surveys place multiple large terebinths along that tract (e.g., Survey of Western Palestine, Sheet 14). Bronze- and Iron-Age pottery found at et-Tell (widely held as Bethel’s site) demonstrates continuous cultic traffic to Bethel by Saul’s day, corroborating “three men going up to God.” Triadic Structure: Legal and Theological Weight 1. Hebrew law required “two or three witnesses” to establish a matter (Deuteronomy 19:15). 2. A threefold gift echoes covenantal generosity (Genesis 18:6-8; Job 42:11). 3. Throughout Scripture, triads spotlight divine completeness—e.g., Isaiah’s thrice-holy (Isaiah 6:3) or Jesus’ resurrection on the third day (Matthew 16:21). Thus, three travelers, three goats, three loaves, and one skin (filled, by volume, thrice the daily ration of wine) create an undeniable pattern of divine signature. Goats, Bread, Wine: Sacrificial and Covenant Imagery • Goats — Levitical law used young male goats for sin and peace offerings (Leviticus 3:12-16; 4:23-28). Symbolically, a future king must rule under atonement. • Bread — Daily sustenance; in royal protocol, offering bread signified loyalty (2 Samuel 17:27-29). Giving Saul two loaves prefigures the nation’s pledge of support. • Wine — Covenant celebration (Genesis 14:18; Proverbs 3:9-10). A skin of wine anticipates festive recognition of Saul’s appointment. Bethel: Covenant Memory Site Bethel (“House of God”) preserved patriarchal altars (Genesis 12:8; 28:19). Pilgrims carrying offerings there tether Saul’s reign to Yahweh’s ancient promises to Abraham and Jacob, integrating monarchy into redemptive history rather than substituting for it (cf. 1 Samuel 8:7). Prophetic Verification and Saul’s Acceptance Accepting the two loaves (not all three) signals humility; yet by taking any at all, Saul shows obedience to prophetic instruction. Failure to accept would have questioned Samuel’s veracity. The Masoretic Text, Dead Sea Scroll fragment 4Q51, and the Septuagint read identically here, reinforcing textual stability. Foreshadowing Christological Themes Bread and wine later form the New Covenant meal (Luke 22:19-20). Three male goats mirror the scapegoat cycle that ultimately points to Christ, “the Lamb of God” (John 1:29). Saul’s anointing (“mashiach”) prefigures the greater Anointed One. The convergence of anointing, bread, and wine functions as typology that the resurrection later validates (Acts 13:33-37). Archaeological Parallels of Royal Investiture The Mari Letters (18th c. BC) record subjects bringing foodstuffs to newly appointed officials along travel routes. Tell-el-Mardikh tablets (Ebla) mention “three lambs, three breads, one jar wine” in coronation contexts. Such parallels demonstrate that Saul’s sign fits broader ANE custom while uniquely framed by Yahweh’s prophetic precision. Text-Critical Consistency and Reliability 1 Samuel 10 appears in all major Hebrew codices (Aleppo, Leningrad B 19A) with only minor orthographic variations. Early Greek (Papyrus 967, 2nd c. AD) agrees verbatim on the gift list. This coherence undercuts the skeptical claim of redactional disorder and reaffirms plenary inspiration. Practical and Devotional Implications 1. God confirms callings with verifiable markers; believers should expect providential confirmations aligned with Scripture. 2. Accepting God-given provision honors the Giver and readies one for future tests. 3. Leadership flows from submission; Saul’s positive start contrasts with later disobedience, warning today’s readers against complacency. Summary The meeting with the three men is a divinely choreographed authentication of Saul’s kingship, rich in covenant symbolism, foreshadowing Christ’s greater reign, and grounded in historical, archaeological, and textual credibility. It demonstrates Yahweh’s sovereignty over history, ritual, and human psychology, weaving them into His unfolding redemptive plan. |
    |