Why does Numbers 31:35 include women as part of the spoils of war? Historical Background To Numbers 31 The Midianites first appear in direct opposition to Israel when they join Moab in hiring Balaam (Numbers 22). Their strategy turns from cursing to corrupting: “The women invited the people to the sacrifices of their gods… and the LORD’s anger burned against Israel” (Numbers 25:2-3). Twenty-four thousand Israelites die (Numbers 25:9). Yahweh therefore commands: “Harass the Midianites and strike them” (Numbers 25:17). Numbers 31 records the fulfillment of that judicial order, not a capricious raid but a divinely sanctioned act of retributive justice against a nation that had intentionally weaponized sexual immorality and idolatry. Divine Judgment And Moral Rationale Numbers 31:2 frames the mission as “vengeance for the sons of Israel against the Midianites.” The Hebrew naqam (vengeance) denotes lawful retribution, not personal revenge. The Midianite males and the women who had participated in the seduction campaign (Numbers 31:16) are executed; the virgins—“all the women who had not lain with a man” (Numbers 31:35)—are spared. This distinction reflects culpability: those directly involved in the earlier atrocity receive capital punishment; the uninvolved young women do not. Scripture is consistent that God’s judgments differentiate between the guilty and innocent (cf. Genesis 18:25; Deuteronomy 24:16). Why Include Virgin Women Among The Spoils? 1. Preservation of Life Unlike surrounding cultures that often exterminated entire populations, the LORD orders that innocent life be preserved (cf. Deuteronomy 20:13-14 for distant cities). The 32,000 virgins in Numbers 31:35 live precisely because God intervenes to protect rather than annihilate. 2. Assimilation and Provision Mosaic regulations for female captives (Deuteronomy 21:10-14) grant them food, shelter, mourning time, marital rights, and freedom from perpetual slavery. They may become wives with full covenantal protection or remain servants protected by laws against abuse (Exodus 21:26-27; Leviticus 25:43). Far from endorsing exploitation, Torah places strict limits on Israelite treatment of these women. 3. Covenant Witness Incorporation into Israel exposes captives to Yahweh’s covenant, offering spiritual redemption (cf. Rahab, Joshua 6; Ruth the Moabitess). The spared Midianite virgins receive a future within a community uniquely bound to God, contrasting pagan practices that left captives with no hope of integration. Distribution Details And Safeguards Numbers 31:26-47 outlines an exact division: half to the warriors, half to the congregation, with mandatory offerings to the LORD—1 in 500 from the soldiers’ portion and 1 in 50 from the people’s portion. Even the living captives are counted as spoil so that the entire nation acknowledges God’s ownership and sovereignty. The priestly and Levitical shares ensure continual oversight, minimizing private mistreatment. Comparison With Ancient Near Eastern Warfare Contemporary Hittite, Assyrian, and Egyptian texts (e.g., “Annals of Thutmose III”) boast of total genocide and forced labor. In contrast, Israel’s system: • distinguishes combatants from non-combatants, • demands ritual purification for captives and soldiers alike (Numbers 31:19-24), • provides rights unknown elsewhere. Archaeologist K. A. Kitchen notes that Israelite war codes are “exceedingly restrained” next to prevailing Near Eastern norms (On the Reliability of the Old Testament, 2003, p. 176). Archaeological Corroboration Of Midian Midianite “Qurayyah Painted Ware” (13th-12th c. BC) excavated at Timna and Qurayyah verifies a flourishing Trans-Jordanian/Arabian culture matching the biblical locale. Egyptian texts (Papyrus Harris I, ca. 1150 BC) list “Midian” among regions pacified during the late Bronze Age, aligning with Israel’s chronicle of conflict. These external controls root Numbers 31 in real people and places, not myth. Addressing Modern Ethical Objections 1. Slavery? Mosaic servitude differs fundamentally from New-World chattel slavery. Captives possessed legal recourse, could not be kidnapped (Exodus 21:16), and were to be released upon severe injury (Exodus 21:26-27). 2. Misogyny? Torah elevates female dignity: captives granted a month to mourn (Deuteronomy 21:13), sexual coercion prohibited (Deuteronomy 22:25-27), and husbands commanded lifelong provision (Exodus 21:10). 3. Genocide? The campaign is limited, targeted, and judicial. Midianite clans persist afterward (Judges 6), demonstrating that Numbers 31 is not ethnic eradication but punitive justice toward a coalition guilty of a specific offense. Theological Significance God’s handling of Midian underscores His holiness: sin has consequences, yet mercy is extended to the repentant and innocent. The spared virgins foreshadow the gospel pattern—deserving judgment, humanity finds rescue through divine initiative (Romans 5:6-8). Integration of outsiders anticipates Christ’s inclusion of Gentiles (Ephesians 2:12-13). Conclusion Numbers 31:35 records virgin women among the spoil not to sanction misogyny or slavery, but to highlight God’s justice against willful evil, His mercy toward the innocent, and His provision of legal protections far ahead of surrounding cultures. The passage coheres with the entire Scriptural witness of a holy yet compassionate God who ultimately offers redemption to all nations in Jesus Christ. |
    |