Why was Merab given to Adriel instead of David, as promised in 1 Samuel 18:19? Setting the Scene • 1 Samuel 17:25 promised Saul’s oldest daughter to the man who struck down Goliath. • After David’s victory, Saul stalls, watching David’s growing popularity (1 Samuel 18:6–9). • Saul then renews the promise in 1 Samuel 18:17, offering Merab if David will “fight the LORD’s battles.” David’s Humble Response • “Who am I…that I should become the king’s son-in-law?” (1 Samuel 18:18). • David’s words suggest he felt unworthy, lacked the customary bride-price, and would accept only if Saul insisted. • His humility left room for Saul to maneuver. Saul’s Changing Motives • Jealousy: “Saul eyed David from that day on” (1 Samuel 18:9). • Fear: “The LORD was with David but had departed from Saul” (1 Samuel 18:12). • Plotting: Saul hoped David would fall in battle (1 Samuel 18:17, 25). When that failed, he looked for another snare. Immediate Reason Merab Was Given to Adriel • Scripture states the fact without commentary: “When the time came for Merab…she was given to Adriel of Meholah as a wife” (1 Samuel 18:19). • From the flow of the chapter, the simplest reading is that Saul deliberately broke his word: – David had fulfilled the battle condition. – Saul still feared David’s rise and did not want him as a son-in-law. • By handing Merab to Adriel, Saul: – Avoided strengthening David’s claim to the throne by marriage to the firstborn princess. – Kept control of succession politics inside his preferred circles (Adriel was allied to Saul’s tribe, Benjamin, through Meholah’s location in tribal territory). • Saul’s character pattern—rash vows, later reversal (cf. 1 Samuel 14:24–45)—shows a habit of expedient decisions over covenant faithfulness (contrast Numbers 30:2; Psalm 15:4). Why Saul Could Still Offer Michal • Giving Merab elsewhere freed Saul to dangle a second daughter as fresh bait (1 Samuel 18:20–21). • Michal “loved David,” a fact Saul exploited, thinking “She may be a snare to him” (v. 21). • The required bride-price of 100 Philistine foreskins (v. 25) set a deadly risk far higher than any dowry expected for Merab. Larger Theological Takeaways • Human schemes cannot thwart God’s anointed purpose; despite Saul’s duplicity, David advanced (Romans 8:31). • Rash promises quickly discarded reveal a double-minded heart (Proverbs 20:25; James 1:8). • God’s sovereignty over family lines: Merab’s marriage produced five sons later executed for Saul’s sin (2 Samuel 21:8–9), while Michal’s union sheltered David and preserved the Messianic line. • Believers are warned against envy and manipulation, called instead to integrity and trust in the LORD’s timing (Proverbs 3:5–6; Psalm 37:7). |
    |