Why were Israelites uncircumcised then?
Why were the Israelites in Joshua 5:5 uncircumcised during their wilderness journey?

Circumcision: The Covenant Marker from the Beginning

Genesis 17:10-11: “This is My covenant… Every male among you must be circumcised. You are to circumcise the flesh of your foreskin, and this will be a sign of the covenant between Me and you.”

• The eighth-day rite identified every son of Abraham as belonging to the LORD’s promises (Leviticus 12:3).


What Joshua 5:5 Reports

• “Though all the people who came out had been circumcised, none of those born in the wilderness along the way after they had come out of Egypt had been circumcised.”

• Two facts stand out:

‑ The Exodus generation (those twenty and older in Numbers 14:29) were circumcised.

‑ The sons born during forty years of wandering were not.


Why the Wilderness-Born Were Uncircumcised

1. Consequence of Corporate Unbelief

Numbers 14:32-33: “Your bodies will fall in this wilderness… Your sons will be shepherds in the wilderness forty years, bearing the brunt of your unfaithfulness.”

• The sign of covenant inheritance was suspended while the unbelieving generation lived under judgment.

2. Life Outside the Land of Promise

• The Abrahamic sign pointed to the land inheritance (Genesis 17:8).

• Because the parents forfeited entry, God withheld the mark until their children actually crossed into the land (Joshua 5:6-7).

3. Continuous Movement and Hardship

Deuteronomy 8:4 recalls the rigors of wandering: clothes and sandals never wore out, yet there were no stable settlements.

• Surgical recovery in desert camps repeatedly breaking down and moving would endanger life (Genesis 34:24-25 illustrates vulnerability after the procedure).

4. Divine Discipline, Not Divine Neglect

Psalm 78:10-11 notes Israel “did not keep God’s covenant, refused to walk in His law.”

• The LORD never revoked His promise; He waited to renew it with the obedient generation.


The Moment of Renewal at Gilgal

Joshua 5:2-3: “At that time the LORD said to Joshua, ‘Make flint knives and circumcise the sons of Israel again.’”

• Now the wilderness judgment is finished; covenant heirs stand in the land; the sign fittingly returns.


God’s Faithfulness Shines Through

• Even when people fail, “the gifts and the calling of God are irrevocable” (Romans 11:29).

• Circumcision at Gilgal re-sealed Israel to the covenant, just before Passover (Joshua 5:10) and the conquest.


Takeaway Truths

• Sin may delay blessing, but it cannot nullify God’s sworn promises (Numbers 23:19).

• Covenant signs matter; they testify that God’s Word is literal and reliable.

• Renewal follows repentance and obedience, always on God’s timetable.

What is the meaning of Joshua 5:5?
Top of Page
Top of Page