Must Christians tithe to the storehouse per Malachi 3:10? Definition and Background Tithing, commonly understood as giving one-tenth of one’s income or produce, appears prominently in the Hebrew Scriptures (e.g., Genesis 14:18–20; Leviticus 27:30). In Malachi 3:10, the text reads, “Bring the full tithe into the storehouse, so that there may be food in My house. Test Me in this,” says the LORD of Hosts. “See if I will not open the windows of heaven and pour out for you blessing without measure.” This command was issued to ancient Israel, addressing their covenant obligations and their neglect in supporting the temple and its Levitical system. The primary question is whether Christians today are similarly bound by this directive to bring ten percent of their income specifically to a local church (sometimes called the “storehouse”). Understanding the historical context of Malachi’s message and the New Testament teachings on giving are key to forming a comprehensive conclusion. Historical Context of Malachi 3:10 Malachi prophesied in the post-exilic period of Israel’s history. The Jewish people had returned from Babylonian captivity and were rebuilding both their civic life and temple worship. The “storehouse” refers to the physical rooms or chambers in the temple where offerings of grain, wine, and oil were kept (cf. Nehemiah 10:38–39). During Malachi’s ministry, many Israelites were failing to provide the necessary resources to sustain the priesthood and help the poor in the community. The tithe supported the Levites, who had no defined land inheritance of their own (Numbers 18:21–24). Hence, the command in Malachi 3:10 carried both a moral and covenantal force for Israel at that time. Archaeological excavations in Jerusalem and surrounding regions have uncovered evidence of rooms and treasury chambers that align with Old Testament descriptions of temple storehouses. These findings help illustrate the practical infrastructure that made collecting and distributing tithes feasible in that era. The Meaning of “Storehouse” 1. Ancient Setting The term “storehouse” in Malachi directly references the temple in Jerusalem. It functioned as a central point where the people’s agricultural and livestock offerings were gathered. 2. Contemporary Usage Some modern interpretations equate the “storehouse” with the local church, suggesting that Christians should give their tithe as a parallel to the Old Testament system. However, others argue that the Old Testament temple system was unique, pointing out that the New Testament does not explicitly require believers to replicate Israel’s temple practices. Transition from Old Covenant to New Covenant Under the Mosaic Covenant, tithing was both a civic duty and a religious obligation (see Leviticus 27:30). When the New Covenant was inaugurated by Christ’s atoning work and resurrection (cf. Hebrews 8:6–13), the ceremonial and civic aspects of the Old Covenant—including certain temple-based practices—were fulfilled or superseded (cf. Matthew 5:17). The New Testament affirms that believers are not bound by the entirety of the Old Mosaic Law in its original form (Acts 15:19–29; Galatians 3:23–25). Instead, they are under the “law of Christ” (Galatians 6:2), which emphasizes love, generosity, and willingness to support fellow Christians, ministers, and outreach efforts. New Testament Teachings on Giving 1. Generous and Willing Hearts The Apostle Paul teaches believers to give “not reluctantly or under compulsion, for God loves a cheerful giver” (2 Corinthians 9:7). This principle highlights voluntary generosity rather than strict adherence to a mandated amount. 2. Proportionate Giving In 1 Corinthians 16:2, Paul instructs believers: “On the first day of the week, each of you should set aside a portion of his income, saving it up, so that when I come no collections will be needed.” This statement suggests planned, consistent giving but does not specify a fixed percentage. 3. Support for Ministers and the Needy Multiple New Testament passages encourage believers to support spiritual leaders (1 Timothy 5:17–18) and those in need (Romans 15:26; Galatians 2:10). These teachings reflect the broader idea of stewardship and sacrificial giving rather than a strict Old Testament legal framework. Interpreting Malachi 3:10 for Christians 1. Principle of Faithful Stewardship Malachi 3:10 emphasizes bringing the “full” tithe as a sign of trust in God’s provision. Although directed to Israel under the Old Covenant, the broader principle remains relevant: believers are called to practice regular, faithful giving as a demonstration of gratitude and reliance on God. 2. Principle of Testing God “Test Me in this,” says the LORD in Malachi 3:10. While testing God often carries a negative connotation in Scripture (Deuteronomy 6:16; Matthew 4:7), Malachi uniquely portrays God inviting Israel to experience His blessing through obedience in giving. Christians today might glean a principle: genuine faith in God’s goodness can be shown through acts of generosity, trusting that He provides for His people. 3. Christ’s Fulfillment of the Law Because Christ has fulfilled the Old Testament sacrificial and temple-based system, the tithe’s function in supporting the Levitical priesthood does not directly transfer to the church. Yet the moral and spiritual impulses behind it—support, grateful giving, caring for ministers—do find continuity in the New Testament commands to care for one another and faithfully fund ministry work. Applications in Modern Church Context 1. Local Church Support Many Christians see the local church as a primary avenue for giving. Supporting the local fellowship’s needs—pastoral staff, missions, community services—can mirror the Israelite practice of ensuring the temple stood as a resource for worship and community welfare. 2. Other Avenues of Generosity Beyond local church giving, believers may invest in missions, parachurch ministries, and direct acts of charity, reflecting the spirit of the New Testament’s whole-life stewardship. The emphasis is on generous and joyful giving rather than solely on a single, rigid mechanism. 3. Starting Point vs. Principle Some Christians use ten percent as a guideline or starting point for their own giving, viewing it as a helpful benchmark rather than an absolute requirement. Others advocate for more, if they are able, since the New Testament speaks more to abundant generosity than to a fixed numerical standard. Key Considerations and Concerns 1. Heart Attitude Scriptural giving principles consistently focus on the giver’s heart, underlining that generosity arises from love and faith rather than external obligation. 2. Accountability and Transparency The storehouse system under the Old Covenant ensured safety and equitable distribution. Today, churches and ministries should similarly uphold financial integrity and transparency when receiving and administering funds. 3. Prayerful Discernment Each believer is encouraged to seek God’s guidance in determining how much to give. Prayerful reflection, conversation with church leadership, and studying the biblical texts help form a conviction rooted in Scripture and faith. Conclusion Malachi 3:10’s call to “bring the full tithe into the storehouse” was specifically directed to the Israelites under the Old Covenant to support the temple-centered worship system. While Christians no longer live under the same covenant, the underlying principles of cheerful generosity, trust in God’s provision, and supporting the ministry of the gospel remain firmly in place. Numerous New Testament passages encourage believers to give generously and joyfully toward the work of ministry, the needs of the poor, and fellow believers. Whether or not one adopts a strict ten percent guideline, the spirit behind Malachi 3:10 endures: a willing, faithful, and sacrificial offering that acknowledges God’s sovereignty and brings glory to Him. Thus, while Christians are not bound by a precise Old Testament storehouse tithe command, they are called to practice generous, voluntary, and consistent giving. This posture of stewardship reflects a New Covenant ethos, centering on gratitude, support of ministry, and love for both God and neighbor. |
    |