Motive: Misunderstood: when They Built the Memorial
Jump to: Nave'sLibrarySubtopicsTerms
Topical Encyclopedia
In the biblical narrative, the concept of motive plays a significant role, particularly when actions are misinterpreted by others. A notable instance of misunderstood motive is found in the account of the construction of a memorial by the tribes of Reuben, Gad, and the half-tribe of Manasseh, as recorded in the Book of Joshua.

Context and Background

After the Israelites, under Joshua's leadership, had taken possession of the Promised Land, the tribes of Reuben, Gad, and the half-tribe of Manasseh were granted land on the eastern side of the Jordan River. Before returning to their allotted territories, these tribes had fulfilled their commitment to assist the other tribes in conquering the land west of the Jordan (Joshua 22:1-4).

The Building of the Memorial

Upon their return, these eastern tribes constructed a large altar by the Jordan River. This act was immediately met with suspicion and alarm by the other Israelite tribes, who perceived it as a potential act of rebellion against the LORD. The western tribes feared that this altar signified a departure from the central place of worship established at the Tabernacle in Shiloh, which could provoke divine wrath upon the entire nation (Joshua 22:10-12).

Misunderstanding and Clarification

The western tribes, led by Phinehas the priest and ten chiefs, confronted the eastern tribes to address the perceived transgression. They expressed their concern that the altar represented a breach of faith and a violation of the covenant with God, reminiscent of past transgressions such as the sin of Peor and Achan's disobedience (Joshua 22:13-20).

In response, the eastern tribes clarified their intentions. They explained that the altar was not meant for sacrifices or offerings, but rather as a witness and a memorial. Their motive was to ensure that future generations would recognize their shared heritage and allegiance to the LORD, despite the geographical separation by the Jordan River. They feared that in time, their descendants might be excluded from the community of Israel and the worship of the LORD (Joshua 22:21-29).

Resolution and Reconciliation

Upon hearing the explanation, Phinehas and the leaders were relieved and satisfied. They acknowledged the sincerity of the eastern tribes' motive and praised God for preventing conflict among the Israelites. The altar was thus named "A Witness Between Us that the LORD is God," symbolizing unity and shared faith (Joshua 22:30-34).

Theological Implications

This episode underscores the importance of understanding and discerning motives in the community of faith. It highlights the potential for misunderstanding and conflict when actions are judged without seeking clarification. The narrative also emphasizes the value of dialogue and reconciliation in maintaining unity among God's people. The eastern tribes' desire to preserve their identity and connection to the LORD serves as a reminder of the significance of shared faith and covenantal relationships within the broader community of believers.
Nave's Topical Index
Joshua 22:9-34
And the children of Reuben and the children of Gad and the half tribe of Manasseh returned, and departed from the children of Israel out of Shiloh, which is in the land of Canaan, to go to the country of Gilead, to the land of their possession, whereof they were possessed, according to the word of the LORD by the hand of Moses.
Nave's Topical Index

Library

Pagan Cemeteries.
... urns are round, some square, the motive of the ... the trade, and who, having misunderstood
the directions of ... metal, glass, and enamel; and they represent elephants ...
/.../lanciani/pagan and christian rome/chapter vi pagan cemeteries.htm

Introduction. Chapter i. --The Life and Writings of St. Hilary of ...
... the West; and the disciple of Origen, who found his natural allies in the Cappadocian
school of Basil and the Gregories [1] , his juniors though they were, was ...
/.../introduction chapter i the life and.htm

Resources
What does the Bible say about dyeing hair? | GotQuestions.org

How can I stop being a people-pleaser? | GotQuestions.org

What does it mean that “as a man thinks, so is he” in Proverbs 23:7? | GotQuestions.org

Motive: Dictionary and Thesaurus | Clyx.com

Bible ConcordanceBible DictionaryBible EncyclopediaTopical BibleBible Thesuarus
Subtopics

Motivation

Motive

Motive: Ascribed to God

Motive: Misunderstood: David's, by King Hanun

Motive: Misunderstood: Job's, in his Righteousness

Motive: Misunderstood: The King of Syria's, in Sending Presents to the King of Israel by Naaman

Motive: Misunderstood: The Tribes of Reuben and Gad, in Asking for Their Inheritance East of the Jordan River

Motive: Misunderstood: when They Built the Memorial

Motive: Right, Required

Motive: Sinful, Illustrated by Cain

Related Terms

Guilt (180 Occurrences)

Charity (29 Occurrences)

Innocents (2 Occurrences)

Massacre (1 Occurrence)

For (102061 Occurrences)

Spring (122 Occurrences)

Latin (2 Occurrences)

Confusion (71 Occurrences)

Manasses (1 Occurrence)

Motives (13 Occurrences)

Job (60 Occurrences)

Separate (115 Occurrences)

Adoption (5 Occurrences)

Abomination (78 Occurrences)

General (9 Occurrences)

Respect (204 Occurrences)

Version

Resurrection (42 Occurrences)

Tongues (67 Occurrences)

Year (4027 Occurrences)

Veil (67 Occurrences)

Zoroastrianism

Obeying (24 Occurrences)

Obligate (2 Occurrences)

On (40792 Occurrences)

Operative (2 Occurrences)

Occasion (53 Occurrences)

Object (76 Occurrences)

Joab (128 Occurrences)

Jael (6 Occurrences)

Leading (101 Occurrences)

Governor (78 Occurrences)

Wrestling (8 Occurrences)

Wing (18 Occurrences)

Instance (9 Occurrences)

Incentive (1 Occurrence)

Imitation (3 Occurrences)

In (142459 Occurrences)

Integrity (46 Occurrences)

Impulse (18 Occurrences)

Figure (19 Occurrences)

Track (4 Occurrences)

Toil (66 Occurrences)

Tithe (30 Occurrences)

Take (11064 Occurrences)

Toiling (8 Occurrences)

Rebekah (31 Occurrences)

Refer (4 Occurrences)

Reason (438 Occurrences)

Euodia (1 Occurrence)

Eyeservice (2 Occurrences)

Eager (43 Occurrences)

Ever-living (20 Occurrences)

Excitement (4 Occurrences)

Motions (2 Occurrences)

Mad (22 Occurrences)

Madness (13 Occurrences)

Mankind (80 Occurrences)

Mary (50 Occurrences)

Mean (93 Occurrences)

Parallel (6 Occurrences)

Pomegranate (11 Occurrences)

Purim (5 Occurrences)

Pur (3 Occurrences)

Pretext (11 Occurrences)

Policy (3 Occurrences)

Barabbas (10 Occurrences)

Commandment (209 Occurrences)

Commentaries

Cause (1309 Occurrences)

Consideration (8 Occurrences)

Amon (20 Occurrences)

Account (460 Occurrences)

Ahithophel (17 Occurrences)

Animal (163 Occurrences)

Anxiety (24 Occurrences)

Air (74 Occurrences)

Spent (76 Occurrences)

Strain (5 Occurrences)

Motive: Misunderstood: The Tribes of Reuben and Gad, in Asking for Their Inheritance East of the Jordan River
Top of Page
Top of Page