Does 1 Samuel 28:16 suggest that mediums can truly contact the dead? Canonical Context and Narrative Setting 1 Samuel 28 describes Saul’s final hours before his death at Mount Gilboa. Yahweh has departed from him (1 Samuel 28:15), prophetic voices are silent (1 Samuel 28:6), and Saul, in desperation, seeks a ’ôb (“medium”) at Endor—an act he himself had outlawed (1 Samuel 28:3). The scene is deliberately framed to highlight Saul’s apostasy and the contrast between the once‐chosen king and Samuel, the prophet who had earlier anointed him (1 Samuel 10:1). Universal Biblical Prohibition of Necromancy • “You must not allow a sorceress to live.” (Exodus 22:18) • “Let no one be found among you … who consults the dead.” (Deuteronomy 18:10-11) • Mediums receive the death penalty (Leviticus 20:6, 27). These texts show that necromancy is condemned and powerless to achieve God’s favor. Saul’s turning to a medium is, therefore, a final act of rebellion, not a legitimate avenue of revelation. Possible Explanations Considered 1. Demonic Impersonation: Many hold the apparition to be a demonic deception. Yet the content of the oracle is faithful to Yahweh’s previous word, something demons consistently distort (John 8:44). 2. Psychological Illusion: A hallucination is ruled out by the medium’s shock (1 Samuel 28:12) and by the fulfillment of the prophecy. 3. Divine Exception: The majority view in historic Judaism (Josephus, Antiquities 6.335) and early Christianity (Justin, Dialogue 35) is that God Himself interrupted the séance, truly raising Samuel to pronounce judgment. This accords with God’s sovereignty (Isaiah 46:10) and the biblical pattern of using extraordinary means to deliver decisive revelation (e.g., Numbers 22:28-30). The State of the Righteous Dead Before Christ’s Resurrection Samuel, though deceased, is portrayed as conscious in Sheol (cf. Genesis 37:35; Isaiah 14:9). His appearance prefigures Jesus’ teaching that the righteous dead live to God (Luke 20:38) and aligns with the transfiguration where Moses and Elijah converse with Christ (Matthew 17:3). Divine Sovereignty Overrides Occult Practice Rather than validating witchcraft, the passage showcases Yahweh’s supremacy: • The medium screams in fear—she is not in control (1 Samuel 28:12). • Samuel’s first words denounce Saul’s occult resort (1 Samuel 28:16-18). • God’s decree, not the séance, determines the outcome (1 Samuel 28:19). Thus, 1 Samuel 28:16 illustrates that God can pierce even forbidden venues to accomplish His will, while simultaneously condemning those venues. New Testament Echo and Final Verdict 1 Chronicles 10:13-14 interprets the event: “Saul died for his unfaithfulness … and also because he consulted a medium for guidance, but did not inquire of the LORD.” Scripture itself denies that Saul legitimately accessed divine favor through necromancy. Rather, God judged him for seeking it. Theological Summary • Mediums have no intrinsic power to summon the dead; Scripture universally forbids and discredits the practice. • 1 Samuel 28 portrays a unique, divinely initiated appearance of Samuel to announce irrevocable judgment, not validation of spiritism. • Any seeming contact with the dead today is either fraudulent or demonic (2 Colossians 11:14-15). Repentance and consultation of God’s word, not occultism, bring truth (Isaiah 8:19-20). Practical Implications for Today 1. Reject all forms of necromancy, séances, and occult exploration. 2. Seek guidance solely from Scripture and the risen Christ, “for there is one God and one mediator between God and mankind, the man Christ Jesus” (1 Titus 2:5). 3. Recognize that death is not annihilation; accountability before God remains (Hebrews 9:27). Salvation and true communion with the eternal realm come only through the resurrected Lord (John 11:25-26). |
    |