How should Christians interpret "hate" in Psalm 139:21? Text of Psalm 139:21–22 “Do I not hate those who hate You, O LORD, and detest those who rise against You? I hate them with perfect hatred; I count them as my enemies.” Genre: Imprecatory Elements Within a Psalm of Intimacy Psalm 139 oscillates between personal devotion (vv. 1-18, 23-24) and covenant litigation against rebels (vv. 19-22). This literary device—moving from the intimacy of God’s omniscience to the courtroom setting of divine justice—highlights that true worship includes alignment with God’s moral order. The “hate” is therefore covenantal, not spiteful: a formal denunciation akin to a prosecutor’s closing statement. Canonical Context: Hatred Toward God’s Enemies 1 Samuel 15:2-3; 2 Chronicles 19:2; and Psalm 97:10 (“O you who love the LORD, hate evil”) establish the pattern: love for God entails repudiation of unrepentant evil. The imprecatory motif serves three functions: 1. Vindication of God’s honor (Psalm 83:16-18). 2. Protection of the covenant community (Psalm 5:10). 3. Warning to the wicked that mercy has boundaries (Proverbs 1:24-31). Thus David’s “hate” mirrors divine justice rather than personal animus. Distinction Between Personal Malice and Covenant Loyalty Leviticus 19:17 commands, “You shall not hate your brother in your heart.” The same chapter demands love for neighbor (v. 18). These injunctions forbid private bitterness while permitting judicial opposition to persistent covenant-breakers. David’s declaration is public, liturgical, and judicial—he is taking Yahweh’s side against those who defiantly hate God. Ethical Trajectory From Old Testament to New Testament While the Old Testament allows and at times commands judicial hatred of evil, it simultaneously seeds the principle of redemptive mercy (Exodus 34:6-7; Ezekiel 18:23). The prophetic expectation culminates in Christ’s call to love enemies (Matthew 5:44), a command that does not abrogate the moral revulsion toward sin but reorients the believer’s posture from legal imprecation to evangelistic intercession (Romans 12:14-21). Jesus’ Teaching on Loving Enemies Jesus quotes Psalm-like imprecation (Luke 19:27) in an eschatological key, reserving final judgment for His return (John 5:22). In His earthly ministry He models forgiveness (Luke 23:34) while warning of coming wrath (Matthew 23). The believer therefore hates evil ideologically yet loves evil-doers personally, reflecting simultaneous truths: God “is angry with the wicked every day” (Psalm 7:11) and “desires all people to be saved” (1 Timothy 2:4). Apostolic Echoes and Balance Paul cites an imprecatory psalm in Romans 11:9-10, affirming its validity yet coupling it with intercessory longing for Israel’s salvation (Romans 10:1). John commands love (1 John 4:7-21) while labeling false teachers “antichrists” (2 John 7-11). Jude urges the church to “save others, snatching them out of the fire, yet hating even the garment stained by the flesh” (v. 23). Apostolic praxis unites moral hatred of sin with compassionate pursuit of sinners. Psychological and Behavioral Dimensions Hatred, if self-centered, corrodes (Proverbs 14:30). Covenant-aligned hatred, by contrast, externalizes moral outrage in the presence of community and before God, preventing vigilante justice. Behavioral studies on moral injury (Meta-analysis: Dean & Talbot, 2019, Journal of Religion and Health) show the therapeutic value of lament and imprecation for victims of evil, validating the psalmist’s pattern as psychologically sound when tethered to divine adjudication rather than personal revenge. Practical Pastoral Application 1. Worship Context: Use Psalm 139:21-22 as corporate lament against systemic evil (e.g., abortion, human trafficking). 2. Personal Devotion: When confronting injustice, voice lament to God first, then pray for perpetrators’ repentance. 3. Evangelism: Expose sin’s gravity (Romans 6:23) while extending Christ’s offer of forgiveness (John 3:16). 4. Self-Examination: Follow David’s own pivot—“Search me, O God” (Psalm 139:23-24)—guarding against hypocritical hatred. Summary “Hate” in Psalm 139:21 speaks of covenantal, judicial repudiation of persistent, God-hating evil, not private malice. The New Testament recalibrates this stance through the lens of Christ’s atoning work, directing believers to love enemies personally while still despising sin and longing for God’s just verdict. Properly interpreted, the passage harmonizes with the wider biblical ethic, satisfies emotional justice, and undergirds evangelistic urgency. |
    |