What does Luke 17:23 mean by "do not go out or chase after them"? Text and Immediate Context “People will tell you, ‘Look, there He is,’ or ‘Look, here He is.’ Do not go out or chase after them.” (Luke 17:23) The warning falls within Jesus’ reply to Pharisees who asked when the kingdom would come (17:20-37). Verses 20-21 stress that the kingdom is not inaugurated by visible political spectacle, and verses 22-25 prepare disciples for a period of longing in which they will be vulnerable to rumors. Verse 23 supplies the prohibition; verse 24 immediately explains why: “For just as the lightning flashes and lights up the sky from one end to the other, so will the Son of Man be in His day.” Because the authentic return will be sudden, public, and unmistakable, any report that requires searching Him out is automatically false. Broader Lucan and Synoptic Setting Luke parallels Matthew 24:23-27 and Mark 13:21-23. In every Synoptic instance the counsel is identical: spectacular, localized claims (“He is in the wilderness,” “He is in the inner rooms”) are to be rejected. Luke alone places the material before the Olivet Discourse, forming an inclusio that brackets Jesus’ eschatological instruction. The structure underscores continuity: one coherent message delivered on different occasions—no contradiction among Gospel witnesses. Historical Background: First-Century Messianic Pretenders Josephus (Jewish War 2.259-263; Antiquities 20.97-99, 168-172) lists Theudas, the Egyptian, and numerous unnamed figures promising deliverance. Acts 5:36-37 corroborates: “For some time ago Theudas rose up… After him, Judas the Galilean… and all who followed him were scattered.” Jesus’ audience knew such movements; His command anticipates the impulse to seek nationalistic or mystical fulfilment in human leaders. Theological Significance: Nature of the Parousia Scripture presents a singular, bodily, cosmic return (Acts 1:11; 1 Thessalonians 4:16-17; Revelation 1:7). Luke 17:24’s lightning imagery signals universality and sudden visibility; 17:26-30 likens the day to Noah and Lot—inescapable for believer and unbeliever alike. Because the real event needs no herald other than its own glory, any claim that depends on secrecy or geography denies New Testament eschatology. Discernment and False Prophets Through the Ages • Second-century: Montanus promised a new Jerusalem in Phrygia. • Twelfth-century: Rabbi Moses of Crete claimed he would part the sea; many drowned following him. • Nineteenth-century: Millerite prediction of 1844’s “Great Disappointment.” • Twentieth-century: Sun Myung Moon, David Koresh, Jim Jones—all invoked Christlike authority. Each episode fulfilled Jesus’ forecast (Matthew 24:24), reinforcing the standing relevance of Luke 17:23. Practical Implications for Believers Today A. Stay anchored in Scripture (2 Timothy 3:15-17). B. Evaluate claims by the apostolic gospel (Galatians 1:8-9). C. Remain engaged in ordinary faithfulness (“occupy till I come,” Luke 19:13 KJV). D. Reject date-setting (Acts 1:7). Sensationalism distracts from evangelism and sanctification. Relation to Other Biblical Passages • Deuteronomy 13:1-4—test of prophets; fidelity to Yahweh outweighs signs. • Isaiah 8:20—“To the law and the testimony!” safeguards against occult searches. • 2 Thessalonians 2:1-12—“man of lawlessness” and deceptive wonders. • 1 John 2:18—“many antichrists have appeared.” Luke 17:23 is an early warning of the same phenomenon. Psychological Dimensions of Apocalyptic Hysteria Behavioral studies note “availability cascades”—social amplification of rumor leads to collective action. Jesus pre-empts this cognitive vulnerability: expect deception; do not act on unverified novelty. The instruction is prophylactic psychology embedded in divine revelation. Pastoral and Evangelistic Application When unbelievers point to sects or scandals as grounds for skepticism, Luke 17:23 demonstrates that Christ anticipated counterfeit claims. The existence of impostors validates, not invalidates, His prophecy. Presenting the authentic, risen Christ (1 Corinthians 15:3-8) steers seekers away from human saviors toward the Lord who historically rose, was seen by hundreds, and whose return will be equally historical and public. Conclusion “Do not go out or chase after them” forbids physical participation and mental investment in any movement announcing a localized or secret reappearance of Christ. The true Parousia will be unmistakable, global, and self-authenticating, rendering every rumor irrelevant. The verse thus cultivates discernment, steadiness, and hope fixed on the sovereign timetable of the Lord of Glory. |
    |