How does Romans 13:7 align with the concept of separation of church and state? Romans 13:7 “Pay everyone what you owe him: taxes to whom taxes are due, revenue to whom revenue, respect to whom respect, honor to whom honor.” Purpose and Scope Romans 13:7 is frequently raised in discussions about whether Scripture supports or challenges the modern idea of “separation of church and state.” The phrase itself arose centuries after Paul wrote, yet the principle it names—distinct but related spheres of civil and spiritual authority—can be traced directly to biblical teaching. This entry surveys the text, its vocabulary, historical setting, related passages, theological implications, historical practice, and practical application. Immediate Context in Romans 13 Paul’s exhortation (13:1-7) follows eleven chapters of salvation doctrine and a twelfth on transformed living. The flow is deliberate: because believers are saved by grace, they now submit their bodily lives (12:1-2) and social lives (12:9-21) to God. The civil sphere comes next. The basic rule: governing authorities are “servants of God” (13:4), appointed to restrain evil and promote the common good. Verse 7 supplies four concrete duties—taxes, revenue (customs), respect, and honor. Historical Setting: Under Nero, Before the Fire Paul likely wrote in A.D. 57–58 during Nero’s early years, before the great fire of 64 and the brutal persecutions that followed. Government was pagan, flawed, sometimes corrupt—yet God still used it to maintain order. Thus submission could not be contingent on a government’s righteousness; it rested on God’s overarching providence (cf. Daniel 2:21). Intertextual Harmony 1. Matthew 22:21—“Render to Caesar the things that are Caesar’s, and to God the things that are God’s.” Jesus declares two realms of rightful claim. 2. 1 Peter 2:13-17—Peter echoes Paul nearly verbatim, adding, “Fear God, honor the king.” 3. Acts 5:29—“We must obey God rather than men.” Civil obedience has a ceiling; when commands clash, divine authority prevails. 4. Daniel 3 & 6; Exodus 1—Old Testament precedents for conscientious civil disobedience clarify the boundaries. Together, these passages reveal complementary, not competing, authorities. Biblical Theology of Dual Spheres Scripture presents God as sovereign over all (Psalm 24:1) and delegates limited authority to distinct institutions: family (Genesis 2:24), civil government (Genesis 9:6; Romans 13), and church (Matthew 16:18-19; 18:17-20). Each sphere answers to God and must not usurp the other’s God-assigned jurisdiction. This is the true root of “separation,” not secular isolation of faith but differentiation of institutional roles. Limits and Responsibilities of the State Romans 13 assigns government two basic tasks: 1. Restrain/punish evil (vv. 3-4). 2. Praise/protect good (v. 3). When it strays—e.g., legislating moral wrongs or persecuting righteousness—citizens may appeal, protest, or, as a last resort, disobey (Acts 5:29) while accepting consequences (Daniel 6:16). Obligations of the Church and Individual Believers 1. Pay lawful taxes and customs (Romans 13:7). 2. Pray for rulers (1 Timothy 2:1-4). 3. Speak prophetically to power (2 Samuel 12; Matthew 14:4). 4. Model goodness that “silences the ignorance of foolish men” (1 Peter 2:15). 5. Maintain the gospel mission; civil engagement must never eclipse evangelism. Separation of Church and State: Conceptual Clarification • Negative Sense (Not Biblical): Religion confined to private life; God banished from public discourse. • Positive Sense (Biblical): Distinct jurisdictions preventing coercion of conscience or government control of doctrine. The church wields the Word and sacraments; the state wields the sword of justice (Romans 13:4). Both operate under divine oversight. Early Christian Practice Justin Martyr wrote to Antoninus Pius, “Wherever we are, we more readily than all men endeavor to pay taxes to those appointed by you” (First Apology, ch. 17). Tertullian echoed, “No tax-gatherer goes from us unsatisfied” (Apology, ch. 42). Archaeological corroboration, such as papyri tax receipts from Oxyrhynchus (P.Oxy. 254), shows Christians integrated into the fiscal life of the empire, fulfilling Romans 13:7 even while refusing emperor worship. Historical Development Toward Modern Western Practice Augustine distinguished the City of God from the Earthly City, influencing medieval debates. The Reformation sharpened the divide: Luther’s “two kingdoms,” Calvin’s distinction of ecclesiastical and civil offices, and English separatism all drew on Romans 13. The American founders, many steeped in Reformed thought, adopted legal non-establishment to prevent either sphere’s tyranny over the other, reflecting biblical precedent rather than repudiating it. Answering Common Objections • “Submission equals theocracy.” Not so. Romans 13 prescribes submission to even pagan rulership, revealing that Christian faith thrives under plural governmental forms without demanding confessional states. • “The verse forces believers to obey unjust laws.” Acts 5:29 and Daniel’s examples set a higher-law exception. Christians refuse evil orders but still honor the office (respect/honor) and bear penalties without vengeance. • “Church and state must not interact at all.” Paul explicitly interacts: he invokes his Roman citizenship (Acts 22:25), appeals to Caesar (Acts 25:11), and leverages state courts for gospel advance (Philippians 1:12-13). Interaction is inevitable; Scripture regulates, not eliminates, it. Practical Implications Today 1. Vote, lobby, and serve in office as expressions of stewardship, all while remembering that the gospel, not legislation, regenerates hearts. 2. Pay taxes with integrity, resisting fraud as a form of theft (Eighth Commandment). 3. Educate consciences to honor officials in speech (James 3:9-10), even while opposing unrighteous policies. 4. Support just laws that protect religious liberty, family definition, and life, because government is accountable to divine moral order. Systematic Harmony With Intelligent Design and Creation Timeline The biblical worldview grounding Romans 13 assumes a Creator who orders both natural and social realms (Genesis 1; Colossians 1:16-17). Recognizing government as an ordinance of that Creator aligns with empirical observations of design—systems regulated by information and purpose. The moral law “written on their hearts” (Romans 2:15) parallels the coded information in DNA: both arise from the same rational Mind, reinforcing the legitimacy of moral governance rather than undermining it. Eschatological Note Human governments are temporary. Christ will return to “rule the nations with a rod of iron” (Revelation 19:15). Until then, believers practice provisional loyalty—faithful citizenship on earth, ultimate citizenship in heaven (Philippians 3:20). Conclusion Romans 13:7 does not contradict the healthy separation of church and state; it undergirds it. The verse commands Christians to discharge civic debts—financial and interpersonal—while recognizing the government’s delegated authority and God’s supreme sovereignty. In rendering Caesar his due and God His greater due, the church bears witness to a balanced biblical model that protects conscience, restrains evil, and magnifies the gospel of the risen Christ. |
    |