Why did Joseph advise his brothers to say, "We have tended livestock"? The Setting in Pharaoh’s Palace Joseph prepares his family for their first audience with Pharaoh (Genesis 46:31-33). He knows Egyptian culture, court politics, and Pharaoh’s temperament. Their words will decide where they live and how they are treated. Why Shepherds Were “Detestable” to Egyptians • Egyptians venerated cattle and certain deities connected with the Nile; nomadic herdsmen threatened those sacred herds. • Shepherds lived outside Egypt’s refined urban life, carrying the stigma of roughness and ritual impurity (cf. Genesis 46:34; Exodus 8:26). • History shows Egypt prized agriculture on irrigated land; wandering flock-keepers were viewed as disorderly outsiders. Joseph’s Threefold Strategy 1. Separation for Holiness – By admitting they were lifelong livestock keepers, the brothers would be placed in Goshen, a frontier district (Genesis 47:1-6). – Goshen’s distance guarded Israel from Egyptian idolatry, preserving covenant identity (cf. Genesis 46:3; Leviticus 20:26). 2. Provision and Protection – Goshen was fertile pastureland—ideal for flocks during famine (Genesis 45:10-11). – Living near Joseph (but not in the capital) ensured swift aid without constant court scrutiny. 3. Position with Purpose – Pharaoh still needed skilled herdsmen for royal livestock (Genesis 47:6). – By presenting themselves as experts, the brothers gained lawful residence and employment while remaining distinct. Covenant Implications • God had foretold that Abraham’s offspring would sojourn in a foreign land yet grow into a great nation (Genesis 15:13-14). • Goshen’s isolation became the incubator for that multiplication (Exodus 1:7). • Joseph’s counsel upheld God’s larger plan: Israel in Egypt, but not of Egypt—a picture later echoed for believers (2 Corinthians 6:17). Take-Home Insights • Wise, truthful speech can position God’s people for blessing without compromise (Proverbs 16:13). • Distinct living is not separatism for pride’s sake but protection for promise’s sake. • God orchestrates even cultural prejudices to advance His redemptive plan (Romans 8:28). |
    |