Why does Job feel the absence of an arbiter in Job 9:33? Historical and Literary Context Job 9 is Job’s direct response to Bildad’s traditional retribution theology. Job concedes that God is righteous (vv. 2–12) yet insists that no mere human can litigate successfully against the Almighty. Verse 33 crystallizes his dilemma: “There is no arbiter between us, to lay his hand upon us both” . Behind the lament lies a fourth–millennium-BC Near-Eastern legal culture in which contested cases were settled by a mutually recognized šar, “judge/arbitrator,” who placed his hands on both parties to symbolize jurisdiction. Numerous cuneiform contracts from Mari and Nuzi show the physical gesture that Job references, and Akkadian law collections (e.g., Code of Hammurabi §§ 5–9) describe a nîš mišitti, “man of arbitration,” who guarantees equity when one party lacks standing. Job sees no such figure operating between finite man and the infinite God. Job’s Perceived Transcendental Gap 1. Divine Ineffability (9:11): “Were He to pass me, I would not see Him.” 2. Cosmic Disproportion (9:32): “For He is not a man like me, that I might answer Him.” 3. Judicial Imbalance: God both prosecutor (v. 14) and judge (v. 15). Job feels procedurally cornered: lex talionis without due process. Behaviorally, acute suffering narrows cognitive bandwidth; modern trauma research confirms that pain skews appraisal toward perceived isolation. Job’s lament is therefore psychologically credible while remaining theologically profound. Progressive Revelation of a Mediator Old-Covenant glimpses: • Exodus 32:32 – Moses offers substitutionary intercession. • Psalm 110:4 – a priest “forever … after the order of Melchizedek.” • Isaiah 53:12 – the Servant “makes intercession for the transgressors.” Yet none fulfills Job’s legal criterion; each lacks ontological parity with Yahweh. The tension remains until the fullness of time (Galatians 4:4). Christological Resolution 1 Timothy 2:5 answers Job: “For there is one God and one mediator between God and men, the man Christ Jesus” . The incarnate Son “lays His hand upon us both” by assuming true humanity while remaining fully divine (John 1:14; Colossians 2:9). His bodily resurrection (1 Corinthians 15:3–8) validates His jurisdiction, supplying the vindication Job longed for. Early creedal citations (e.g., the pre-Pauline formula in 1 Corinthians 15) pre-date A.D. 40, demonstrating that Christian proclamation of a risen Mediator arose within the lifetime of eyewitnesses—meeting stringent historiographical criteria of multiple attestation, enemy attestation (Matthew 28:12–15), and early proclamation. Philosophical Implications A universe devoid of mediation collapses into either fatalistic determinism (Bildad’s framework) or existential despair (Job’s immediate fear). The moral law etched into human conscience (Romans 2:14–15) hungers for an objective ground of reconciliation. Natural-law reasoning, irreducible to biochemical determinism, concurs: personal guilt demands personal atonement, not probabilistic processes. Thus Job’s intuition aligns with the best of analytic philosophy and behavioral science regarding moral agency. Pastoral and Devotional Application Believers share Job’s finitude, yet unlike Job they stand post-Calvary. The completed canon reveals the Mediator, permitting confidence to “approach the throne of grace with boldness” (Hebrews 4:16). Sufferers today can lament honestly while anchoring hope in a resurrected Advocate who “always lives to intercede for them” (Hebrews 7:25). Key Cross-References • Job 16:19–21 – early intimation of a heavenly witness. • Job 19:25–27 – “I know that my Redeemer lives.” • Psalm 49:7 – “No man can redeem his brother.” • Isaiah 59:16 – “He saw that there was no one … so His own arm brought salvation.” • John 14:6; Romans 5:1; Hebrews 9:15. Conclusion Job’s sense of the absence of an arbiter arises from (1) the legal conventions of his era, (2) his acute awareness of God’s transcendence, and (3) the stage of redemptive history in which the ultimate Mediator had not yet been revealed. Scripture’s unified testimony shows that the longing voiced in Job 9:33 is perfectly and exclusively answered in the incarnate, crucified, and risen Christ, who alone bridges the infinite qualitative gulf between holy Creator and fallen creature. |
    |