Why does 1 Timothy 5:23 advise using wine instead of relying solely on faith for healing? Text Of 1 Timothy 5:23 “No longer drink only water, but use a little wine for the sake of your stomach and your frequent ailments.” Immediate Context Within The Epistle Paul writes to Timothy, the young pastor in Ephesus (1 Timothy 1:3), instructing him on pastoral conduct, church order, and personal holiness. Verses 5:22–25 discuss purity, caution in appointing elders, and practical living. The health note in verse 23 is not an isolated digression; it models balanced discipleship: personal responsibility under divine sovereignty. Historical And Cultural Background Greco-Roman water sources were often polluted; fermentation rendered wine mildly antiseptic (Pliny, Natural History 23.20). Archaeological residues from 1st-century amphorae in Ephesus confirm wine routinely mixed with water at ratios as high as 20:1, primarily for purification rather than inebriation. Early Christian texts (Didache 10) reflect the same custom. Timothy’s abstention likely reacted to ascetic false teachers who “forbid marriage and require abstinence from foods” (1 Timothy 4:3). Paul counters ascetic legalism while avoiding excess. Paul’S Pastoral Wisdom: Means And Miracles Together Paul himself healed the sick (Acts 28:8–9) yet travelled with Luke the physician (Colossians 4:14). Scripture never pits medical means against divine power; rather, God ordinarily works through means He ordained in creation (Psalm 104:14). Miraculous intervention is exceptional (1 Corinthians 12:9); prudent use of available remedies is ordinary. Proverbs 22:3 commends foresight; James 2:16 rebukes empty well-wishes without practical help. Biblical Precedent For Medicinal Remedies • Isaiah directed Hezekiah to apply a fig poultice (2 Kings 20:7). • The good Samaritan poured “oil and wine” on wounds (Luke 10:34). • Ezekiel spoke of trees whose leaves are “medicine” (Ezekiel 47:12). These texts illustrate medicine as God’s provision, not a rival to faith. Theological Foundation: Divine Providence And Human Stewardship Creation is orderly and intelligible (Genesis 1; Romans 1:20). By designing a world with stable natural processes, God invites human investigation and application for health (Genesis 1:28). Employing those processes honors, rather than diminishes, the Creator. Prayer asks God to bless ordinary means; it does not negate them (Nehemiah 4:9). Paul’s counsel embodies this synergy. Early Church Commentary • Chrysostom (Hom. 15 on 1 Tim) notes Paul’s caution: “little wine,” avoiding drunkenness yet rejecting ascetic extremes. • Clement of Alexandria (Paedagogus 2.2) defends moderate medicinal use of wine. Such witness shows the verse was understood as pastoral health advice, not license for excess nor denial of faith. Scientific Insight Into Wine’S Medicinal Value Modern microbiology (e.g., antimicrobial studies in Applied and Environmental Microbiology, 1995) demonstrates wine’s phenolic compounds inhibit E. coli, Salmonella, and H. pylori—common causes of gastrointestinal distress. Resveratrol and tannins exhibit anti-inflammatory properties beneficial to digestive ailments. These findings corroborate Paul’s pragmatic recommendation. Balancing Faith And Practice: A Behavioral Perspective Behavioral science affirms that health outcomes improve when spiritual conviction partners with responsible action. Locus-of-control studies (e.g., Wallston & Wallston, 1981) show optimal coping when individuals perceive both divine care and personal agency. Paul fosters such agency in Timothy. Addressing Misinterpretations 1. It does not teach social drinking without restraint; Paul elsewhere condemns drunkenness (Ephesians 5:18). 2. It does not deny miraculous healing; Paul prescribes a commonplace remedy in a non-miraculous circumstance. 3. It does not weaken faith; it exemplifies trusting God’s provision through creation. Practical Application For Modern Believers Seek medical counsel and employ available treatments while praying for God’s blessing. Accept that abstinence from lawful gifts may hinder well-being if motivated by legalism. Exercise moderation, gratitude, and stewardship. Synthesis With The Biblical Witness On Healing Scripture presents three complementary modes: 1. Providential maintenance via creation’s resources (1 Timothy 5:23). 2. Prayer and community support (James 5:14–16). 3. Direct divine intervention (Acts 3:6–8). All converge to glorify God, the ultimate healer (Exodus 15:26). Conclusion 1 Timothy 5:23 underscores that genuine faith receives God’s gifts—natural and supernatural alike. Using wine medicinally manifests obedient stewardship, rejects ascetic error, and harmonizes with a biblical worldview in which the Creator ordained both prayer and practical care for the body He has fearfully and wonderfully made (Psalm 139:14). |
    |