Why did Jesus ask, "Where have you laid him?" if He is all-knowing? Biblical Text “and He said, ‘Where have you laid him?’ They replied, ‘Lord, come and see.’” (John 11:34) Contextual Setting Bethany, two miles east of Jerusalem, has drawn mourners for four days; Lazarus’ body is sealed in a rock-cut tomb. Moments earlier Jesus openly wept (v. 35). He has already declared, “I am the resurrection and the life” (v. 25), promising to display God’s glory (v. 40). The Divine Omniscience of Christ John repeatedly testifies that Jesus “knew all men” (2:24), “knew from the beginning” who would betray Him (6:64), and “knew everything that was coming upon Him” (18:4). Omniscience is inseparable from His deity (cf. Colossians 2:9). The question, therefore, cannot arise from ignorance but from purposeful restraint of knowledge, pastoral method, and revelatory design. Purpose of the Question • Pastoral and Relational Engagement Questions invite participation. By asking Mary, Martha, and the mourners to escort Him, Jesus draws them into the unfolding miracle, allowing them to articulate their grief and exercise trust through physical movement. Behavioral studies confirm that active involvement deepens emotional processing; Scripture regularly mirrors this (Psalm 62:8). • Invitation to Witness He ensures a crowd is literally “on site” to verify both the death (seeing the tomb) and the resurrection. First-century Jewish law required multiple witnesses (Deuteronomy 19:15); Jesus’ request gathers those witnesses for an incontrovertible sign (cf. 11:45). • Affirming the Reality of Death Opening the tomb exposes the odor of decomposition (v. 39). Acknowledging the exact burial place underscores the historical, physical reality of Lazarus’ death, pre-empting later naturalistic objections (cf. Matthew 28:13–15). • Preparatory Step for Miracle Jesus often commands preparatory actions—“Fill the jars with water” (John 2:7), “Have the people sit down” (6:10). Here, the command “Show Me” precedes “Remove the stone” (11:39), rhythmically staging divine intervention through human obedience. Analogous Divine Questions in Scripture • “Where are you?” (Genesis 3:9) – God sought relational confession, not information. • “Whom shall I send?” (Isaiah 6:8) – an invitation to volunteer. • “Son of man, can these bones live?” (Ezekiel 37:3) – a prelude to revelation. Such questions are pedagogical, drawing humans into dialogue and decision. The Hypostatic Union and Omniscience in Incarnation Philippians 2:6-8 teaches that the Son, “existing in the form of God,” did not surrender deity but “emptied Himself” by assuming true humanity. The early church framed this as the communicatio idiomatum: attributes of either nature are predicated of the one Person. Thus Jesus can experience genuine human limitation in expression while retaining omniscience in essence. Exercising or veiling divine prerogatives remains at His sovereign discretion (Mark 13:32). Grammatico-Historical Insights Greek τίθημι (tithēmi) in perfect active indicative (“have you laid”) emphasizes a completed action with continuing result: Lazarus lies immovably dead. The second-person plural “you” involves the whole group, reinforcing communal accountability. Patristic and Historical Commentary Augustine: “He asked not for ignorance but to stir their hearts.” Chrysostom: “He converses humanly, that none should deem His incarnation a phantom.” These ancient expositors unanimously interpret the query as pedagogic, not epistemic. Practical and Devotional Applications Believers may confidently bring locations of pain (“where have you laid him?”) to the Lord who already knows yet invites disclosure. Evangelistically, the account models asking questions that expose the hearer’s spiritual “tombs” before presenting resurrection hope. Conclusion Jesus’ question was not born of ignorance but of intentional, pastoral, evidential, and theological purpose. It harmonizes flawlessly with His omniscience, His incarnational mission, and His desire to involve people in witnessing the revelation of God’s glory. |
    |