Why did some people recognize Jesus as the Prophet in John 7:40? Definition of “the Prophet” In first-century Judea “the Prophet” (ὁ προφήτης) was a technical title drawn from Deuteronomy 18:15–18. Moses had promised: “The LORD your God will raise up for you a prophet like me from among your brothers. You must listen to him.” . Rabbinic writings (e.g., Sifre Deuteronomy 34:10), Qumran scrolls such as 4Q175, and Josephus (Ant. 5.112) all show that Israel expected a single eschatological figure who would speak God’s final word, perform Mosaic-type signs, and inaugurate the new covenant era. Messianic Taxonomy in A.D. 30 Many Jews distinguished three end-time roles: (1) the Messiah-King (2 Samuel 7), (2) Elijah (Malachi 4:5), and (3) “the Prophet” (Deuteronomy 18). John 1:19-25 records priests from Jerusalem asking John the Baptist whether he is “the Christ,” “Elijah,” or “the Prophet,” proving these were living categories. Thus when the crowd at the Feast of Tabernacles exclaimed, “Surely this is the Prophet” (John 7:40), they were recognizing Jesus in that third category. Immediate Context: Jesus’ Words at the Feast of Tabernacles 1. Setting—“the last and greatest day of the feast” (John 7:37). The daily water-drawing procession from the Pool of Siloam reminded Israel of the wilderness rock that Moses struck (Exodus 17). 2. Jesus’ claim—“If anyone is thirsty, let him come to Me and drink” (v. 37). By presenting Himself as the true source of living water, He implicitly paralleled Moses’ miracle yet surpassed it (Isaiah 55:1; Zechariah 14:8). 3. Result—Some listeners linked this Mosaic imagery to Deuteronomy 18, declaring Him “the Prophet.” Mosaic-Type Miracles Already Witnessed • Turning water to wine (John 2) recalls Moses turning water to blood (Exodus 7). • Feeding 5,000 with bread in the wilderness (John 6) echoes manna (Exodus 16). After this sign the crowd had already said, “This is truly the Prophet who is to come into the world” (John 6:14). • Walking on the sea (John 6:19) evokes Israel’s Red Sea crossing led by Moses. These parallels were fresh in popular memory only months before John 7, buttressing the identification. Prophetic Authority in Teaching Moses spoke face to face with God (Exodus 33:11). Similarly, Jesus taught without citation of prior rabbis, saying, “My teaching is not My own. It comes from Him who sent Me” (John 7:16). The crowd sensed the same divine immediacy that characterized Mosaic revelation (cf. Matthew 7:28-29). Scripture Chains Employed by the Crowd First-century Jews used verbal links (“stringing pearls”). Jesus’ allusion to “living water” (Isaiah 12:3; 55:1) and “Scripture has said” (John 7:38) triggered Deuteronomy 18 in listeners trained in synagogue lectionary cycles that paired Deuteronomy 8–18 with water-imagery prophetic readings during Tabernacles. Samaritan Precedent The Samaritan woman concluded, “I perceive that You are a prophet” (John 4:19) and spoke of the coming “Messiah” (4:25). Samaritans held only the Pentateuch, so their messianic hope centered almost exclusively on Deuteronomy 18’s Prophet (called the Taheb). Jesus’ self-revelation to them (John 4:26) had likely circulated, preparing Jerusalem pilgrims to view Him through the same lens. Archaeological Corroboration • Excavation of the Pool of Siloam (2004) locates the very basin used in the Tabernacles water ritual, validating John’s festival description. • The Temple steps and southern gate uncovered by Benjamin Mazar align with pilgrims’ route referenced in the Mishnah (Sukkah 4–5) and assumed in John 7, confirming the narrative’s authenticity. New Testament Confirmation of Jesus as “the Prophet” • Peter: “Moses said, ‘The Lord God will raise up for you a prophet like me.’ … God raised up His Servant and sent Him to bless you” (Acts 3:22, 26). • Stephen: “This is the Moses … He is the one who was in the assembly in the wilderness … This is the Moses who said to the Israelites, ‘God will raise up for you a prophet like me’” (Acts 7:37–38). The earliest Christian preaching identifies Jesus precisely as the Deuteronomy 18 Prophet, matching the crowd’s instinct in John 7:40. Theological Significance Recognizing Jesus as “the Prophet” is a necessary but not sufficient step. Scripture moves from Prophet (Deuteronomy 18) to Messiah-King (Psalm 2) to divine Son (Daniel 7:13-14; John 20:28). John’s Gospel uses the crowd’s identification as a stepping stone toward full confession: “that you may believe that Jesus is the Christ, the Son of God” (John 20:31). Practical Implications 1. Fulfilled prophecy validates the inerrancy of Scripture and the deity of Christ. 2. Believers should present Christ’s Mosaic parallels when evangelizing audiences familiar with the Old Testament. 3. Modern readers must progress from recognizing Jesus as a remarkable teacher to embracing Him as crucified-risen Lord (Romans 10:9). Summary People at the Feast of Tabernacles labeled Jesus “the Prophet” because His Mosaic-type miracles, His living-water proclamation inside a ritual that commemorated Moses, His unparalleled authority, and the era’s scriptural expectations all converged. Their conclusion is historically credible, textually secure, archaeologically supported, and theologically foundational, inviting every generation to heed the divine mandate: “You must listen to Him” (Deuteronomy 18:15). |
    |