Topical Bible: Faith: Trial of of Peter, when Asked Whether he Loved Jesus

◄ Faith: Trial of of Peter, when Asked Whether he Loved Jesus ►

Jump to: Nave's • Library • Subtopics • Terms

Topical Encyclopedia

The trial of Peter's faith, particularly when Jesus asked him about his love, is a significant event recorded in the Gospel of John. This moment is pivotal in understanding the restoration and reaffirmation of Peter's role among the disciples after his earlier denial of Christ. The account is found in John 21:15-17, where Jesus, after His resurrection, engages Peter in a profound dialogue.

Context and Setting

Following Jesus' resurrection, He appeared to His disciples by the Sea of Tiberias. This setting is crucial as it mirrors the environment of Peter's initial calling and his subsequent denial of Jesus during the events leading up to the crucifixion. The disciples had returned to fishing, and after a miraculous catch orchestrated by Jesus, they shared a meal with Him on the shore. It is in this intimate and familiar setting that Jesus addresses Peter directly.

The Threefold Question

In John 21:15-17, Jesus asks Peter three times, "Simon son of John, do you love Me?" Each question corresponds to Peter's threefold denial of Jesus, as recorded in John 18:15-27. The repetition of the question serves as both a reminder of Peter's past failure and an opportunity for redemption and reaffirmation of his commitment to Christ.

1. First Question: "Simon son of John, do you love Me more than these?" (John 21:15). Jesus' inquiry challenges Peter to consider the depth of his love in comparison to the other disciples. Peter responds affirmatively, "Yes, Lord, You know that I love You." Jesus then instructs him, "Feed My lambs," signifying a call to pastoral care and leadership.

2. Second Question: "Simon son of John, do you love Me?" (John 21:16). This question, devoid of comparison, focuses solely on Peter's personal devotion. Peter again affirms his love, and Jesus commands, "Tend My sheep," reinforcing Peter's responsibility to nurture and guide the early Christian community.

3. Third Question: "Simon son of John, do you love Me?" (John 21:17). The third repetition grieves Peter, as it echoes his previous denials. Yet, Peter responds with sincerity, "Lord, You know all things; You know that I love You." Jesus replies, "Feed My sheep," completing the restoration and commissioning of Peter.

Significance and Implications

This exchange between Jesus and Peter is rich with theological and pastoral implications. It highlights the themes of forgiveness, restoration, and the transformative power of Christ's love. Peter's trial of faith is not merely a test but a profound moment of grace, where his past failures are redeemed, and his future mission is affirmed.

The dialogue underscores the necessity of love as the foundation for Christian ministry. Jesus' repeated command to "feed" and "tend" His flock emphasizes the pastoral duty to care for and nurture the spiritual well-being of believers. Peter's restoration also serves as a testament to the possibility of redemption and the renewal of one's calling, even after significant failure.

In this narrative, the trial of Peter's faith becomes a powerful example of how Christ's love and forgiveness can restore and empower believers to fulfill their God-given purposes. The passage invites Christians to reflect on their own love for Christ and their commitment to His mission, encouraging a faith that is both tested and triumphant.

Nave's Topical Index

John 21:16,17
He said to him again the second time, Simon, son of Jonas, love you me? He said to him, Yes, Lord; you know that I love you. He said to him, Feed my sheep.
Nave's Topical Index

Library

The Trial of Peter's Love to Christ.
... he was honored with the name of Peter"an honorable ... into the judgment hall to attend
his trial and witness the ... Thus Simon's faith and love were owned of Christ ...
/.../lee/sermons on various important subjects/sermon xiii the trial of.htm

Jesus and Peter.
... God, and overcame by clinging in faith and trust. ... The splendid Christian manhood
of Peter has been now ... pass through experiences of loss, trial, temptation, and ...
/.../miller/personal friendships of jesus/chapter vii jesus and peter.htm

Entire Sanctification as Taught by Peter.
... After speaking of the "trial of their faith being much ... reason, not by culture, not
by learning, but by faith. ... And so both Peter in speaking about the "sincere ...
/.../clark/the theology of holiness/chapter viii entire sanctification as.htm

John Chapter xxi. 19-25.
... Is not the life of man a term of trial upon earth ... to the Church, whereof the one
is in faith, the other ... was it, then, that John loved Him less than Peter, if he ...
/.../augustine/homilies on the gospel of john/tractate cxxiv john chapter xxi.htm

Jesus and the Beloved Disciple.
... Peter was the mightiest force at the beginning in the founding of ... That is the privilege
of Christian faith. ... for he was close to his Master during his trial. ...
/.../miller/personal friendships of jesus/chapter vi jesus and the.htm

A Mystery! Saints Sorrowing and Jesus Glad!
... God did not deliver me, because the trial has strengthened ... ought to know the grounds
of their faith and practice ... Peter will swing at his girdle; but his time is ...
/.../spurgeon/spurgeons sermons volume 10 1864/a mystery saints sorrowing and.htm

Divine Calls.
... Faith alone can obey them. ... God's servants and children, all through our time of trial,
having been ... sea, "that disciple whom Jesus loved saith unto Peter, It is ...
/.../newman/parochial and plain sermons vol viii/sermon ii divine calls.htm

Gethsemane
... And that for which He made such supplication was, that Peter's faith should not ... that
something new might be given him, or the trial removed from Peter. ...
/.../edersheim/the life and times of jesus the messiah/chapter xii gethsemane.htm

On Patience
... lively is the account which the Apostle Peter gives not ... work of patience," consequent
upon the trial of our ... same proportion as he grows in faith, he grows in ...
/.../wesley/sermons on several occasions/sermon 83 on patience.htm

The Mind which was in Christ Jesus. Rev. George Wood.
... the maintenance of their profession of faith, chiefly from ... in circumstances of adversity
and trial; and both ... He could look conviction into Peter's heart, and ...
/.../king/the wesleyan methodist pulpit in malvern/the mind which was in.htm