What does "all things are clean" mean in Romans 14:20? Canonical Context Romans 14:20 : “Do not destroy the work of God for the sake of food. All things indeed are clean, but it is wrong for a man to let his eating be a stumbling block.” The letter to the Romans, written in the mid-50s A.D., addresses Jew–Gentile tensions in the churches of Rome. Chapters 14–15 focus on disputable matters—chiefly diet and holy days—where believers of differing backgrounds were judging one another. Paul’s aim is unity in the gospel, not uniformity in non-essentials. Immediate Literary Context Verses 14–23 form a single paragraph. Paul has already stated, “I know and am persuaded in the Lord Jesus that nothing is unclean of itself” (v.14), then balances that liberty with the call not to put a brother “at risk of stumbling” (vv.15, 21). “All things are clean” therefore functions inside an ethical syllogism: 1. God has declared food clean. 2. Love requires self-limitation for another’s conscience. 3. So, while all foods are clean, unloving use of that liberty becomes sin. Historical Background of Food Laws 1. Patriarchal Era: In Eden only plants were food (Genesis 1:29–31). After the Flood, God added “everything that moves” (Genesis 9:3). 2. Mosaic Covenant: Leviticus 11 and Deuteronomy 14 distinguished Israel by clean/unclean animals, anticipating Messiah’s holiness. 3. Second Temple Judaism: Dietary boundaries intensified national identity (Josephus, Ant. 3.11.1). 4. New Covenant: Jesus pronounced all foods clean (Mark 7:18-19), later confirmed to Peter in Caesarea (Acts 10:13-16). The Jerusalem Council (Acts 15) required Gentiles only to avoid blood, strangled meat, and idolatry—not Mosaic dietary codes. Theological Fulfillment in Christ Ceremonial laws were “a shadow of the things to come, but the substance belongs to Christ” (Colossians 2:17). His atoning death and resurrection (1 Corinthians 15:3-4; attested in early creeds c. A.D. 35) remove defilement, rendering previous food distinctions obsolete. The tearing of the temple veil (Matthew 27:51) and the resurrection—documented by over five hundred eyewitnesses (1 Corinthians 15:6) and affirmed by minimal-facts scholarship—signal a new covenantal order in which righteousness is imputed, not ingested. Relationship to Other Pauline Passages • 1 Corinthians 8–10: Knowledge of liberty must bow to love; “food will not commend us to God.” • 1 Timothy 4:4–5: “For every creation of God is good, and nothing is to be rejected if it is received with thanksgiving.” • Titus 1:15: “To the pure, all things are pure.” These parallels confirm “all things are clean” is a universal proclamation balanced by situational ethics. Unity, Love, and Conscience A weaker conscience (often Jewish believers attached to Torah) regarded certain meats as defiling. Stronger believers (usually Gentiles) knew freedom. The moral calculus is: • Objective reality: food ≠ moral defilement. • Subjective conscience: violation = sin for that individual (Romans 14:23). • Corporate responsibility: liberty restrained > brother wounded (v.15). Hence, cleanness pertains to the object; sinfulness pertains to relational impact. Practical Applications 1. Dietary Debates Today: Vegan/omnivore, organic/GMO, alcohol, holiday observances—apply Romans 14’s matrix. 2. Mission Field Hospitality: Accept local fare unless clearly idolatrous (1 Corinthians 10:27-28). 3. Health Stewardship: Freedom is not license for gluttony; the body is a temple (1 Corinthians 6:19-20). 4. Evangelistic Sensitivity: Demonstrating sacrificial love authenticates the gospel message. Creation, Design, and Dietary Freedom Modern microbiology reveals irreducible complexity in digestive enzymes that process diverse macros. The designed adaptability of the human gut—from hydrochloric acid levels to villi surface area—supports Genesis 9:3’s permission for omnivory. Geological rapid-burial strata containing varied animal kinds align with a catastrophic Flood model, harmonizing scientific observation with the young-earth timeline and the divine declaration that post-Flood “all things” are provisioned. Eschatological Horizon Isaiah 25:6 foresees a messianic banquet of “rich food and well-aged wine.” The consummation restores Edenic fellowship, where no clean-unclean distinction mars communion. Romans 14:20 previews that freedom. Conclusion “All things are clean” in Romans 14:20 asserts God’s definitive abrogation of ceremonial food restrictions through Christ’s atoning work. The declaration upholds creation’s goodness, secures liberty for the believer, and mandates love-governed restraint for the sake of communal peace and gospel witness. |
    |