Revenge by James and John
Jump to: Nave'sLibrarySubtopicsTerms
Topical Encyclopedia
Introduction

The theme of revenge is addressed in various parts of the Bible, often highlighting the contrast between human inclinations and divine instruction. The account of James and John, the sons of Zebedee, provides a notable example of the human desire for revenge and the corrective teaching of Jesus Christ. This entry explores the incident involving James and John as recorded in the Gospel of Luke, examining the context, motivations, and the response of Jesus.

Biblical Account

The incident involving James and John is found in Luke 9:51-56. As Jesus set His face toward Jerusalem, He sent messengers ahead to a Samaritan village to prepare for His arrival. However, the Samaritans did not welcome Him because His destination was Jerusalem. This rejection prompted a strong reaction from James and John, who asked, "Lord, do You want us to call down fire from heaven to consume them?" (Luke 9:54).

Context and Motivations

James and John, also known as the "Sons of Thunder" (Mark 3:17), were part of Jesus' inner circle of disciples. Their request to call down fire from heaven reflects a zeal for defending Jesus' honor, but it also reveals a misunderstanding of His mission. The Samaritans' refusal to welcome Jesus was rooted in longstanding animosity between Jews and Samaritans, which may have fueled the disciples' desire for retribution.

The request to call down fire echoes the actions of the prophet Elijah, who called down fire from heaven to consume the soldiers of King Ahaziah (2 Kings 1:10-12). James and John likely saw themselves as defenders of the faith, invoking the power of God to punish those who opposed His anointed one.

Jesus' Response

Jesus' response to James and John's request is both immediate and instructive. He turned and rebuked them, saying, "You do not know what kind of spirit you are of; for the Son of Man did not come to destroy men's lives, but to save them" (Luke 9:55-56). This rebuke highlights the contrast between the disciples' desire for vengeance and Jesus' mission of salvation and mercy.

Jesus' correction underscores the New Testament teaching that vengeance belongs to God alone (Romans 12:19). His rebuke serves as a reminder that His kingdom is not advanced through violence or retribution, but through love, forgiveness, and the transformative power of the Gospel.

Theological Implications

The incident with James and John illustrates the tension between human impulses and divine purposes. It serves as a reminder that followers of Christ are called to emulate His example of grace and mercy, even in the face of rejection and hostility. The desire for revenge is a natural human response, but it is one that must be surrendered to the higher calling of love and forgiveness.

This account also highlights the importance of understanding the spirit of Christ's mission. Jesus came to seek and save the lost (Luke 19:10), and His followers are called to participate in this mission by extending grace and compassion, rather than seeking retribution.

Conclusion

The account of James and John seeking revenge provides a powerful lesson on the nature of discipleship and the call to align one's spirit with that of Christ. It challenges believers to resist the urge for vengeance and to embrace the path of love and forgiveness, reflecting the heart of the Savior who came not to destroy, but to save.
Nave's Topical Index
Luke 9:54
And when his disciples James and John saw this, they said, Lord, will you that we command fire to come down from heaven, and consume them, even as Elias did?
Nave's Topical Index

Library

John the Beloved
... He and his brother were called "sons of thunder." Evil temper, the desire for revenge,
the spirit of criticism, were all in ... James and John especially were ...
/.../white/the acts of the apostles/lesson 53 john the beloved.htm

Index.
... James and John, sons of Zebedee, 164, 347. ... Passover, but one in synoptical Gospels,
three in John, 155; first, 168; second, 217; last, 345. ... Revenge, 234. ...
/.../neander/the life of jesus christ in its historical connexion/index 2.htm

"He Ordained Twelve"
... Peter, James, and John stood in still nearer relationship ... Even John, who came into
closest association with ... Evil temper, revenge, the spirit of criticism, were ...
/.../white/the desire of ages/chapter 30 he ordained twelve.htm

Christ Crucified
... to Israel and her monarch, that he saw the way to a petty revenge. ... last ingredient
of human cruelty was infused into the cup which James and John had once ...
/.../chadwick/the gospel of st mark/chapter 15 21-32 christ crucified.htm

C. The Third Period. Chs. 6:12 to 8:56
... First then, in place of all revenge, vs.27-30, Jesus established the Golden Rule ...
not any man to enter in with him, save Peter, and John, and James, and the ...
/.../erdman/the gospel of luke an exposition/c the third period chs.htm

The Life of Mr. James Guthrie.
... and personal pique, as the marquis's was said to be to a more exalted revenge; and
it ... Mr. Arthur Forbes, Mr. John Guthrie, Mr. Hugh Walker, Mr. James Cowie. ...
/.../howie/biographia scoticana scots worthies/the life of mr james 3.htm

Acts XII
... 5. We have noticed that when Peter and John were dismissed from the ... 255] Now that
James has been ... prayer, there is no passion, no thirst for revenge, or purpose ...
/.../mcgarvey/a commentary on acts of the apostles/acts xii.htm

Our Lord in the Garden
... And He taketh with Him Peter and James and John ... John Knox took his wife and said
to her, "Read to me that Scripture on ... Most noble Caesar, we'll revenge His death ...
//christianbookshelf.org/whyte/lord teach us to pray/xi our lord in the.htm

The Conversion of Paul.
... cured and baptized"not by Peter or James or John ... more logical and theological
commentator than John Calvin ... failing in his purpose, he took revenge and attacked ...
/.../history of the christian church volume i/section 31 the conversion of.htm

Christ Crucified and Buried.
... He had been frustrated and galled; and he took his revenge by flashing the ... think
otherwise and suppose that Salome, the mother of James and John, is the ...
/.../the new testament commentary vol iii john/christ crucified and buried.htm

Resources
What is the principle of double effect? | GotQuestions.org

What are some of the most famous sayings of Jesus? | GotQuestions.org

What is imprecatory prayer? | GotQuestions.org

Revenge: Dictionary and Thesaurus | Clyx.com

Bible ConcordanceBible DictionaryBible EncyclopediaTopical BibleBible Thesuarus
Subtopics

Revenge

Revenge by Absalom

Revenge by Ahab

Revenge by Haman

Revenge by Herodias

Revenge by James and John

Revenge by Jezebel

Revenge by Joab

Revenge by Samson

Revenge by Simeon and Levi

Revenge by the Chief Priests

Revenge by the Edomites

Revenge by the Philistines

Revenge: Absalom

Revenge: Ahab

Revenge: Be Thankful for Being Kept from Taking

Revenge: Chief Priests

Revenge: Christ an Example of Forbearing

Revenge: Edomites

Revenge: Forbidden

Revenge: Forbidden by Our Lord

Revenge: Haman

Revenge: Herodias

Revenge: Inconsistent With Christian Spirit

Revenge: Inconsistent With the Will of Christ

Revenge: Instead of Taking, we should Bless

Revenge: Instead of Taking, we should Exercise Forbearance

Revenge: Instead of Taking, we should Exhibit Love

Revenge: Instead of Taking, we should Give Place to Wrath

Revenge: Instead of Taking, we should Overcome Others by Kindness

Revenge: Instead of Taking, we should Trust in God

Revenge: James and John

Revenge: Jesus an Example of Forbearing

Revenge: Jews

Revenge: Jezebel

Revenge: Joab

Revenge: Keep Others from Taking

Revenge: Philistines

Revenge: Proceeds from a Spiteful Heart

Revenge: Punishment For

Revenge: Rebuked by Christ

Revenge: Rebuked by Jesus

Revenge: Samson

Revenge: Simon and Levi

Revenge: The Wicked are Earnest After

Related Terms

Blood-revenge

Revenger (5 Occurrences)

Revengeful (3 Occurrences)

Samson (37 Occurrences)

Vengeance (63 Occurrences)

Onias

Wreak (1 Occurrence)

Tamar (28 Occurrences)

Bloodrevenge

Avenge (27 Occurrences)

Absalom (93 Occurrences)

Revenging (1 Occurrence)

Joab (128 Occurrences)

Anger (387 Occurrences)

Bloodshed (43 Occurrences)

Jacob (361 Occurrences)

Law (670 Occurrences)

Vehement (10 Occurrences)

Zalmunna (9 Occurrences)

Zebah (9 Occurrences)

Never-ending (2 Occurrences)

Olive (61 Occurrences)

Jotham (26 Occurrences)

Lamech (11 Occurrences)

Gibeah (52 Occurrences)

Goel

Fire (602 Occurrences)

Fury (152 Occurrences)

Take (11064 Occurrences)

Repay (79 Occurrences)

Revengefully (2 Occurrences)

Revenged (2 Occurrences)

Refuge (111 Occurrences)

Revels (2 Occurrences)

Dinah (7 Occurrences)

Defence (48 Occurrences)

Defaming (3 Occurrences)

Denounce (8 Occurrences)

Displeasure (12 Occurrences)

Despite (18 Occurrences)

Disdain (6 Occurrences)

Despiteful (3 Occurrences)

Baalhazor (1 Occurrence)

Baal-hazor (1 Occurrence)

Bigthan (1 Occurrence)

Belongs (127 Occurrences)

Bigthana (2 Occurrences)

Clearing (11 Occurrences)

Cruelty (8 Occurrences)

Curse (211 Occurrences)

Cruel (196 Occurrences)

Avenger (18 Occurrences)

Asahel (17 Occurrences)

Approve (14 Occurrences)

Abishai (25 Occurrences)

Amnon (23 Occurrences)

Appetite (22 Occurrences)

Antiochus

Amasa (13 Occurrences)

Approved (18 Occurrences)

Selfsame (18 Occurrences)

Sorrowed (3 Occurrences)

Nest (22 Occurrences)

Tree (245 Occurrences)

Enmity (23 Occurrences)

Malice (24 Occurrences)

Beloved (117 Occurrences)

Cain (18 Occurrences)

Wrought (186 Occurrences)

Sort (143 Occurrences)

Sennacherib (13 Occurrences)

Carefulness (6 Occurrences)

Hatred (30 Occurrences)

Persuaded (40 Occurrences)

Room (174 Occurrences)

Slip (22 Occurrences)

Simon (75 Occurrences)

Pay (212 Occurrences)

Revenge by Herodias
Top of Page
Top of Page